Proposal: NHL Network --- Eichel & Dahlin FOR Hughes & Hischier

[Oddbob]

There is no common ground for a trade here, that's why it's such a bad proposal.
Eichel and Dahlin are stud #1C and #1D

I see both Hughes and Hischier as borderline 1C/great 2C in their prime.

No basis for a trade, sorry

I know there is no trade, my comments were joking about how many of this trade we see.

 

[SJinNewJersey]

Eichel or Dahlin individually is worth both NJD players. To combine both Sabres players is ridiculous.

 

[2 others]

Keep staying in the basement, because that is your destiny with those two as your franchise players.

 

[nightonthesun]

If I worked for NHLN, my favorite thing would be inducing collective aneurysms on the HF trade forum. Well played!

 

[pld459666]

If I'm NJD, I don't even consider this

 

[SJinNewJersey]

Keep staying in the basement, because that is your destiny with those two as your franchise players.

Our franchise players want to play for our team. The only reason threads like this come up is that Eichel doesn't want to play for your team.

 

[Seachd]

You've assumed wrong & that doesn't surprise me. I'm likely older than your biological parents. I was already in college by 1990, well before you were conceived. No need to respond.

Back on Topic: OP- NJ adds a lot, then adds some more.

The fact that you used the phrase “urban colloquialism” unironically shows that you were likely already in college by 1955.

 

[Jerzey Devil]

Dumb trade for both teams. NJ would have to add which makes it even dumber for them. No thanks.

 

[TBF1972]

I should have quoted your opinion only, not the birthday facts

there is chance hughes becomes as good as eichel offensively. he has elite potential in skating, passing and vision. with the right linemates his offensive output could be huge. i can't envision him to develop the complete game eichel offers.
so we seem to disagree regarding hughes offensive ceiling. i probably disagree with more than 25 others on various topics.

 

[TBF1972]

Keep staying in the basement, because that is your destiny with those two as your franchise players.

are you now talking about eichel/dahlin or hischier/hughes?

 

[La Cosa Nostra]

Is this a joke?As an 18 year old Dahlin scored more points then soon to be 20 year old Hughes has scored in 98 career games.

Dahlin>>>Hughes
Eichel>>>>>Hischier

Devils add 3 more top pieces.

 

[devils29]

Keep staying in the basement, because that is your destiny with those two as your franchise players.

You say this as you’re talking about two players who are so much better than NJ that they have been below them in the standings all year... ironic

 

[the Chad Kilger]

Blackwood in that trade would even up everything

agree value wise but buffalo needs a stud Dman and currently Dahlin is their best bet to fill that roll

 

[Rangerboy030]

 

[bellringer77]

Value favors the Devils but a big fat no thank you from this Devils fan.

That’s insane

 

[hidek91]

Both fanbases seem to be unhappy with this trade, as a Devils' fan, I see no reason to that. Hischier and Hughes are both good defensively and exchanging them for Eichel would mean 5 year contention window when he's UFA, create a hole on 2C position and not solve a problem with lack of high quality wingers besides Bratt.

Value may be good for New Jersey but it doesn't make sense.

 

[rangersfansince08]

Value clearly favors NJ. But Sabres would be lucky to get this package when Eichel demands a trade

 

[N.Y. Orangeman]

What a stupid filler put together by a lazy associate producer.

 

[NJDevils#4]

I wouldn’t wanna get involved w adding to this. Plus Eichel probably has had enough of losing so he’d probably throw a fit here.

 

[Jersey Fresh]

Neutral fan here.

Eich+Dahlin

for

Hughes+Hischier+Smith+Blackwood+'21 1st seems fair +Gusev (for closer salary/cap purposes).

LOL

 

[Jersey Fresh]

Keep staying in the basement, because that is your destiny with those two as your franchise players.

Meanwhile, in Buffalo...

 

[Jerzey Devil]

Keep staying in the basement, because that is your destiny with those two as your franchise players.

Whats lower than the basement then?

 

[HogtownSabresfan]

The only way Devils do it is if we get Matt Beniers at the draft and do this deal right afterwards. Id rather not have the Devils just turn into buffalo of the past couple years.

Only Devils fans think this. Eichel has more value than either of the other guys and is locked down at a reasonable $ 10M. Neither Hughes or Hischier are close to Eichel and will likely never be. Their development curve shows them way behind.

Eichel straight up for those two could happen. Dahlin as an extra. Seriously?

 

[2 others]

Only Devils fans think this. Eichel has more value than either of the other guys and is locked down at a reasonable $ 10M. Neither Hughes or Hischier are close to Eichel and will likely never be. Their development curve shows them way behind.

Eichel straight up for those two could happen. Dahlin as an extra. Seriously?

I wouldn't trade him for those two alone. I'd rather have the gold medal than two silver medals.

 

[beowulf]

All due respect to Hischier and Hughes, they don't even come close to getting Eichel and Dahlin.