GeauxPreds1
Registered User
Ryan Ellis, Kyle Turris and Craig Smith for Noah Hanifin and Elias Lindholm.
Ryan Ellis, Kyle Turris and Craig Smith for Noah Hanifin and Elias Lindholm.
Ryan Ellis, Kyle Turris and Craig Smith for Noah Hanifin and Elias Lindholm.
Eh Turris attempts to solve the #1C, though he's ideally a #2, but yeah, not a fan of trading Hanifin for this same way I'm not a fan of trading him for O'Reilly, yet alone throwing in Lindholm as well.This solves zero of Carolina's current issues (#1C/#1G) and gives away two of their biggest trading chips. I wouldn't trade either Hanifin or Lindholm alone for this package without Ellis committing to a reasonable extension (at which point Nashville would just re-sign him). It is just antithetical to what the Canes need to be trading for.
Eh Turris attempts to solve the #1C, though he's ideally a #2, but yeah, not a fan of trading Hanifin for this same way I'm not a fan of trading him for O'Reilly, yet alone throwing in Lindholm as well.
This makes Nashville a worse team. We lose a top pairing RHD defenseman, a no.2 center and a top 6 winger and only bring back a top 4 LHD and a top 6 winger/center. We're essentially giving away a free 20goal 50 point player while our window for the cup is as wide as it's going to be.
Would you do it if we signed Tavares?This makes Nashville a worse team. We lose a top pairing RHD defenseman, a no.2 center and a top 6 winger and only bring back a top 4 LHD and a top 6 winger/center. We're essentially giving away a free 20goal 50 point player while our window for the cup is as wide as it's going to be.
Yeah, your window is now, when your guys would help you the most, ours is a couple of years down the road, where our guys would likely help us the most.
Would you do it if we signed Tavares?