I agree that Siemens is much more aggressive but Musil isnt a prototypical European dman himself. He is no where near as tough and physical as Siemens but he doesnt shy away from dropping the gloves on occasion and does use his body, just doesnt make bone crushing hits. I think Siemens is a better skater then Musil though Musil is strong himself. The thing that I like about Musil is that he has a very mature game that I think will translate way better in to the NHL. He is very steady and plays smart and positionally well, I think this with his skill set will make him a very good NHL dman but at the same time it lowers his production in the WHL where the game is much simpler and taking risks that would kill you in the NHL is worth it, and he doesnt take them. Sometimes players come along that are very good in the WHL but cant translate that to the NHL, and sometimes there are players that come along that are actually better in the NHL then the WHL when comparing them to their peers. Lots of players put up big numbers in the WHL but when they get to the NHL they have to play a responsible game because the risks they are used to taking that result in scoring(or defensive plays that work in the WHL) are easily exploited and they have to adjust their game to the point where the opportunities to produce scoring that they had in the WHL simply disappear(or the defensive plays and habits dont work at the NHL level). Now having said that I think Siemens is a smart dman in his own right, but Musil to me is on another level.
I think Siemens upside is big and his raw talent such as skating is probably a small notch above Musil, but Musil to me is just such a efficient player that already plays the NHL game and his overall skill set just looks perfect. I really see him as a top pairing dman in the NHL and potential star, in Siemens I see the same potential but a much higher chance of not reaching as his game is not at the same NHL level and lots of players cant perform to their abilities with the more complicated NHL game. Thats not to say that I dont think Siemens isnt capable but just that its not easy to put it all together for the next step no matter how good you are. Imo Musil has already put it all together, even though it doesnt show in the WHL where many weaknesses arent exploited like they are in the NHL thus many strengths that are important in the NHL are much less apparent.
I suppose I think Musil is the safer pick and I think the overall potential of both players is similar.
Anyways end of rant, my opinion is really just my opinion, it will be interesting where both these players stand in a few years.
Last edited by a moderator:
