RallyKiller said:
Which player do you guys think was more important to the Oilers of the 80's, Mark Messier or Wayne Gretzky.
Now I know alot of people will say Gretzky easily, but keep in mind Messier won a cup with the Oilers post Gretzky as well as with the Rangers. Meanwhile Gretzky was unable to win a cup away from Mark Messier
And keep in mind that Messier wasn't the MVP of the Oilers Cup run in 1990. Bill Ranford was. And IMO, Esa Tikannen was their second-most valuable player. Tik not only scored over a point per game clip, but effectively checked the best players of every team the Oilers faced. Some of the best work you'll ever see from a defensive forward. Messier tied for the team playoff scoring lead with Craig Simpson, but Ranford and Tik meant more.
The Oilers in 1990 were not just Messier et al. Their success was a reflection of a lot of guys playing the best hockey of their career, especially Ranford, Tikannen and Simpson. Messier was great, he was their captain, but I wouldn't say 1990 was the best hockey of his career. Also, there were six other players from the five Cups in seven years with the Oilers in 1990, including Kurri, Anderson and Lowe. (Grant Fuhr was injured that playoff).
Gretzky was far more valuable to the Kings in 1993 when the Kings reached the Stanley Cup final, than Messier was to the Oilers in 1990 or the Rangers in 1994. Again, Messier was great on those teams, but nothing like Gretzky in 1993.
Glenn Anderson won without Gretzky, but Gretzky never won without Anderson. So what? Rally Killer, that argument is irrelevant. Messier winning without Gretzky is a reflection of the talent that Messier had around him.
Arguments that the Gretzky haters (chooch) conveniently omit (other than the presence of other key players for the Oilers in 1990):
*The Gretzky-led LA Kings (whose only other notable additions were Kelly Hrudey and John Tonelli), defeated the Oilers in the first round of the 1989 playoffs. The Oilers had pretty much the same core as they did in 1988, when they won the Cup without Gretzky.
*The Oilers advanced as far as they did in the 1992 playoffs without Messier, as they did with Messier in 1991.