Proposal: Montreal - Calgary

[johnnyp17]

Montreal
Brendan Gallagher
Nathan Beaulieu
David Desharnais
2x2nd in 2017

Calgary
Kris versteeg
Dougie Hamilton
Micheal Ferland

Click to read more...

 

[Tkachuk Norris]

Soooo bad for Calgary

 

[Flames Fanatic]

Pass.

I love Gallagher, but we need Dougie. Downgrading to Bealieau just makes our defense worse at a time when it's already a trainwreck after the top 3, especially with Brodie not playing like himself.

 

[Moose Head]

The Habs don't really need a top two pairing righty. They'd be weakening the left side plus their top two lines to upgrade on Greg Pateryn. Even though value wise it favours the Habs, I don't think it improves the Habs.

Would love the op for the Habs if Hamilton was a lefty.

 

[Some Other Flame]

Awful.

Hamilton is not available. Flames want to add more grit so Ferland's not going anywhere.

Beaulieu does nothing for Calgary. Gallagher's great but not worth buying high on.

Easy, easy no.

But you guys can have Wideman for something small, like say Byron. Please?

 

[Captain97]

Value wise bad for flames

need wise bad for habs

Noone does this

 

[Beige Van]

Awful.

Hamilton is not available. Flames want to add more grit so Ferland's not going anywhere.

Beaulieu does nothing for Calgary. Gallagher's great but not worth buying high on.

Easy, easy no.

But you guys can have Wideman for something small, like say Byron. Please?

Haha nope. Didn't you guys have a player like Byron once?

 

[CaptainCrunch67]

Really bad for Calgary

 

[Moose Head]

But you guys can have Wideman for something small, like say Byron. Please?

Desharnais is something small.

 

[Mortimer Snerd]

Montreal
Brendan Gallagher
Nathan Beaulieu
David Desharnais
2x2nd in 2017

Calgary
Kris versteeg
Dougie Hamilton
Micheal Ferland

You have got to be kidding!

 

[DJJones]

But you guys can have Wideman for something small, like say Byron. Please?

I have a signed Bryon picture that I won sitting in storage.

Give him back!

 

[Haatley]

Liken Gallagher but not at the cost of Hamilton. Value just isn't close.

 

[Fig]

I wouldn't mind packaging a few pieces for Spulll

 

[Volica]

Hamilton's value is likely all-time high.
This package doesn't sniff him, even though I love Gallagher and Beaulieu I think is a player on the rise; Dougie Hamilton is easily the best piece here (he has more points than the two forwards combined). His possession numbers are also excellent, out of every Dman across the league with more than 750 minutes played his possession numbers are only behind:

Krug
PK
Doughty

Also, he starts 4-7% less of the time in the offensive zone than these three, and only PK starts in the D zone more than him (by 0.5%).

If a team wants Hamilton from Calgary, Dougie that is, they better be ready to pony up a major haul.
Galchenyuk and Mikhail Sergachev would be a good place to start.

 

[tony d]

Yeah, Calgary won't be doing this. Montreal might think about it but it's bad for them too.

 

[Draft Dynasty]

Galchenyuk, Beaulieu, 1st 17, Juulsen VS Tkachuk, Brodie ??

 

[CaptainCrunch67]

Galchenyuk, Beaulieu, 1st 17, Juulsen VS Tkachuk, Brodie ??

Click - hello? Hello?

 

[Volica]

Click - hello? Hello?

Don't want to sound like a dick, or anything, but man... I don't know if there's a piece on Montreal that I'd be happy with if Tkachuk was heading the other way.

I really think this kid is about as untouchable as it comes. I really believe he's going to be the next premier power-forward in the NHL; more or less a Perry clone. When he spends the summer working on foot-speed, this kid'll be a killer.

Edit.
Clearly if the offer was Price, I mean skater.

 

[Draft Dynasty]

Yeah Im a big fan of Tkachuk..think hes going to be a stud.

Was thinking the same thing about Larkin last year too thoo...

Still I think value wise its decent offer. Real possibility here that Chucky end up having a better career then Tkachuk even tho I think Tkachuk is a more complet player.

 

[Flames Fanatic]

Galchenyuk, Beaulieu, 1st 17, Juulsen VS Tkachuk, Brodie ??

Flames just aren't in a position to be moving pieces for quantity. Galchenyuk is awesome, but the rest is a clear downgrade currently.

We aren't good trade partners for the Habs.

 

[Mobiandi]

Why do CGY-MTL proposals always end up with DD coming here? You guys hate him and we have enough mediocre players.

 

[CaptainCrunch67]

Don't want to sound like a dick, or anything, but man... I don't know if there's a piece on Montreal that I'd be happy with if Tkachuk was heading the other way.

I really think this kid is about as untouchable as it comes. I really believe he's going to be the next premier power-forward in the NHL; more or less a Perry clone. When he spends the summer working on foot-speed, this kid'll be a killer.

Edit.
Clearly if the offer was Price, I mean skater.

That's what I was trying to say. Any offer that starts with MT is an instant hangup.

 

[Skobel24]

No chance.

 

[Kritty]

Apparently everyone thinks that arguably the Flames 2 best players this year (along with Backlund) are going to be dealt when one is a rookie and the other only 24 and just scratching the surface of what he can be. And for average pieces on top of that.

On a different note, whatever happened to all that talk about Hamilton being overrated and not as good as people think? I guess that died pretty quickly, just like Flames fans said it should.

 

[Johnnybegood13]

Is this for real or did the OP forget to include Price?

And what's with every Montreal proposal trying to slide in the shrimp Desharnais like nobody would notice?

Let's be clear, Hamilton is quickly reaching #1 status in Calgary, Ferland is becoming a total beast and they are only 23 years old. They won't be traded for spare parts and one smaller sparkplug.