Saw this on MSN and watched as I was interested in the reasons someone would want to get rid of the draft. Turns out this was MLBPA head, and reasons have more to do with CBA than anything.
Abolishing the MLB Draft: How would that work?
His reasons to eliminate the draft:
1) Rather than be drafted and tied to a team players could sign with any team they wanted. True. Seems like top players would tend to gravitate to a few "have" teams, as can happen with free agents.
2) They wouldn't be limited to the tiered signing bonus based on draft slot, they could negotiate the best possible deal for themselves. I'm sure eliminating the draft would require CBA renegotiation, in which the owners would push hard for limits on bonuses for new players. Whether that sticks? Not sure if MLB is like NHL where half the first round still busts but it seems foolish to throw big bonus money at draft picks who are unproven. Maybe this seems skewed because baseball contracts are astronomically outrageous so why not grossly overpay draftees too?
3) Service time requirements would go away? Not sure how they conclude that has anything to do with the draft...As above ownership would fight hard to maintain control of players through first contract or two.
4) Would eliminate tanking. Fair enough...with no reward of high draft pick for finishing low in the standings this incentive goes away. And having a competitive team and history of winning would be a draw for young players. (But not too stacked a roster that a new player couldn't make the team)
Given the source, this is a pipe dream to free new players of any control of ownership and limits on pay. What player wouldn't want that? I'm sure they will want complete removal of any salary cap as well. But seems to me this would completely screw over small market teams.