I liken them Retiring it to the teams that have never won a cup. However, even the Sedin's played in a Stanley Cup Final at least.
List of National Hockey League retired numbers - Wikipedia
When you look at that list, there are two trains of thought I guess:
1) Your team's player either took you to the Promise Land or made it to the HHOF
or
2) Your team honored a player who emphasized your organizations style of play and was a integral part to your success and/or identity
For the longest time, I felt retiring "9" would be a pandering move to appease the fanbase as we've never seen a glorified superstar on the team. Koivu was effectively "it" every year in those rough patches after Gaborik dipped out to New York and before Parise/Suter became complimentary stars to him. However, when you look back at the early 2000's, Koivu was exactly what #2 is. He was the identity of the Minnesota Wild. When you thought of the Wild, you thought of a defensive battle with forwards and that goal scoring was going to be hard. PK was going to be tough. Yes, that probably has changed quite a bit in the time since. But it wasn't always like that. Koivu was consistently put on some of those hyperstars we all wished were on this very team. Even as he aged, he never once appeared to complain that he wasn't getting the easy matchups.
List of National Hockey League retired numbers - Wikipedia
When you look at that list, there are two trains of thought I guess:
1) Your team's player either took you to the Promise Land or made it to the HHOF
or
2) Your team honored a player who emphasized your organizations style of play and was a integral part to your success and/or identity
For the longest time, I felt retiring "9" would be a pandering move to appease the fanbase as we've never seen a glorified superstar on the team. Koivu was effectively "it" every year in those rough patches after Gaborik dipped out to New York and before Parise/Suter became complimentary stars to him. However, when you look back at the early 2000's, Koivu was exactly what #2 is. He was the identity of the Minnesota Wild. When you thought of the Wild, you thought of a defensive battle with forwards and that goal scoring was going to be hard. PK was going to be tough. Yes, that probably has changed quite a bit in the time since. But it wasn't always like that. Koivu was consistently put on some of those hyperstars we all wished were on this very team. Even as he aged, he never once appeared to complain that he wasn't getting the easy matchups.