Ribero was a suitcase because of:
Attitude
Personal life
Defensive game
Well, yeah? Hence him being traded for garbage.
Hornqvist + 12th overall + Spaling vs Chiasson + Paul + Guptill +2nd. It's obvious circumstance lowered his value, as we have an actual offer that a team gave him that somewhat fit his actual value as a player not being affected by having a team over the barrel.
1) Well, I never said that Ribeiro had more value (mainly because of his personal problems), so yes it was expected that Spezza would bring a better package
2) Like Ribeiro, Spezza had many factors against affecting his value (age, chronic back problems, expected quick decline, high contract demands that could make him overpaid very fast, traded as a 1 year rental, not much salary back (only Chiasson), etc)
3) We were not trading away prime Spezza. We were trading away a 31 y/o guy that missed an entire season and then had a very underwhelming season in 2013-14, he did put a good PPG but was horrible defensively, to the point where you could question if he could still be a 1st line Center. At that point, he was more a player of Ribeiro caliber. Very high end playmaking ability, but you have to shelter them so they don't hurt you too much defensively.
4) Yes we had to settle for the 2nd best offer (or maybe there was more good offers but those teams were off Spezza's table). So yeah, among the teams Spezza would go (
and could accommodate him with a big contract to be the 2nd line center), Dallas was probably the best offer. Because of everything that I mentioned in this post (and prior), hard to expect a better return.
5) Teams that didn't go in a bidding war with Dallas were right. 7.5 for your 2nd line center is a lot of money, and thing is he won't be 2nd line worthy in the last 2 years of the contract (out of 4 years). Major bullet dodged for everybody except Dallas. Gosh, imagine how lambasted he would have been if he signed that extension in Ottawa.