I don't disagree, but we are still talking about having to get a guy who needs to be good enough defensively where they are not sheltered, or slightly sheltered. Essentially looking for guys like Travis Dermott. Those guys are not perfect defensively, but they are still pretty good, and those two still have a long way to even get to that level. Dermott can play at least 18 minutes a night and can PK.
The problem with Dermott is he's not driving play offensively unless he's getting bottom competition or defending particularly well
So he's not got the positive attributes to negate the negative attributes going against him like Barrie has
We have a lot of offensive play drivers on the backend so it isn't a need for us but if your defensive unit is offensively challenged somebody that puts up points, drives play offensively that you can shelter has value
For us however those kids need to get better defensively to get a look in, they don't have to be perfect just have the positives outweigh the negatives
We've shown with Barrie we are willing to accept some defensive frailties if you can do other things well enough