How he skates and stick-handles is (to me) very Duchene-like. Shinkaruk definitely has a better shot IMO.
LW Hunter Shinkaruk (2013, 24th, VAN; 2016 traded, CGY)
- Thread starter R S
- Start date
- Status
How he skates and stick-handles is (to me) very Duchene-like. Shinkaruk definitely has a better shot IMO.
Gritty
Registered User
- Nov 28, 2011
- 7,474
- 175
No. I'd say there is probably 3-4 guys that are locked in for top 5 (even that could change).
MacKinnon
Jones
Monohan
Barkov
This draft is so deep, and it's only the beginning of the year.... We could/should have some risers and fallers. It's hard for me to see Shinkaruk out of the top 10, but anything could happen when you got guys like Ristolainen, Pulock, Hagg, Drouin, Domi, Morrissey, Lindholm, Lazar, etc. all in the mix...
i think you're right about the the four...the only others that i could see above shinny are drouin, lindholm and pulock...possibly lazar. it is early tho
sbtatter
Registered User
- Feb 27, 2005
- 2,371
- 9
I think of Duchene as a smoother skater, more cerebal player, better vision, Shinkaruk has high bursts of speed, better shot and more of an attitude, and a lot smaller.
theIceWookie
#LeafHysteriaAlert
People have to remember that he suffered a pretty serious injury after his first season and lost an entire season because of it. It really hit his development hard and it could be argued that he never recovered from it. He's really only played 4 seasons in the NHL and he's a number 1 dman for the Avs. Not exactly the worst back step but think of what could be done with him not missing that year in his development.
rt
The Kinder, Gentler Version
I saw him against the Giants were the Hat played horrible but even with Musil shadowing him all night he had an awesome shift where he exploded and dominated causing Musil to take a penalty.
I haven't seen all the top prospects play but he is a top 5 talent to me and once he fills out a bit he will be a star in the NHL iMO.
SauceHockey
Retired
SauceHockey
Retired
Shinkaruk displyed some pretty good speed, work ethic and hands so far even though Medicine Hat have been terrible in there own end
SauceHockey
Retired
To add more Shinkurak's speed created a chance which caught Lowe flat footed and he had sick pass on the PP but Broissoit made a great save even though he did not do much in the second half of the period
I think it is pretty well established that Duchene blows him out of the water consider skating. True they do have different weaknesses and strength, but they both still look similar to me.
Forward crop in WHL seems historically bad... I think Shinkaruk will be fine, think he will stay in the top 15-20. Compared him to Hishon/Boychuk before in terms of his draft journey before - two slick offensive players who are late birthdays and had big seasons the year before their draft year and then fell back down a bit on draft day from their initial ranking.
I mean I think he'll be fine. From what I've seen he looks better than Hishon and Boychuk...by quite a bit especially if drafted by the right team. But if this trend continues he's gonna lose ground to guys like Drouin, Lazar, Domi, among others.
Gritty
Registered User
- Nov 28, 2011
- 7,474
- 175
CBJWerenski8
Formerly CBJWennberg10 (RIP Kivi)
- Jun 13, 2009
- 42,290
- 24,196
Gritty
Registered User
- Nov 28, 2011
- 7,474
- 175
I just noticed that too! Weird? Maybe it's Blake Kessel trying to cheat the system?
- Status
