Looks like Calder is up for grabs

[The n00b King ©*]

you guys are all wrong

Aki Berg will make a come back and take it all.

Aki Berg's not a rookie?

You have yet to behold the power that is Aki Berg!










(this thread is way too serious for it's own good)

 

[Maitz]

Kopitar , Brule , O'Sullivan , Pouliot , Kostitsyn , Mikhnov , Schremp

everything can happen IMO

 

[GSK*]

Kopitar , Brule , O'Sullivan , Pouliot , Kostitsyn , Mikhnov , Schremp

everything can happen IMO

How you can say is better then the other because he made 47 points in 19 games. ? That didnt mean nothing, he can just be an average NHL players.

Yanic Perreault did 185 points in 67 games in 90-91, and he didnt be a contender for Calder or to be a star.

Patrice Lefebvre did 200 points in 70 games and didnt play 1 game in the NHL...

Stop about Junior stats, thats not mean nothing... At the NHL level, yes, stats mean something, but Junior you cannot even compare LHJMQ against NCAA, they always got lower stats in NCAA or WHL then LHJMQ or OHL.

 

[Debrincat93]

if zetterberg is out for a few weeks to start due to this damn wrist, filppula or hudler could end up breaking a ton of pts if they emerge... never know in dtown

 

[Hemooli]

Even if Malkin plays, he can't possibly be considered a lock for the Calder. No one can.

 

[Missionhockey]

Mikhnov, and with ease.

From the same guy who said that the Devils would trade Scott Gomez for Brad Winchester...

 

[Maitz]

How you can say is better then the other because he made 47 points in 19 games. ? That didnt mean nothing, he can just be an average NHL players.

Yanic Perreault did 185 points in 67 games in 90-91, and he didnt be a contender for Calder or to be a star.

Patrice Lefebvre did 200 points in 70 games and didnt play 1 game in the NHL...

Stop about Junior stats, thats not mean nothing... At the NHL level, yes, stats mean something, but Junior you cannot even compare LHJMQ against NCAA, they always got lower stats in NCAA or WHL then LHJMQ or OHL.

I totally agree with you , I was just naming some of prospect who could maybe win the Calder I know there is something like 20 others one ... Junior means nothing and I know that

 

[monster_bertuzzi]

Let me guess, being from van, you watched alot of giant games? I can understand your love for the guy.

Let me guess, you're a die-hard Oilers fan.

 

[Traktor*]

Let me guess, you're a die-hard Oilers fan.

I bet if you lived in Edmonton and I lived in Van we would be arguing the other way around

 

[monster_bertuzzi]

I bet if you lived in Edmonton and I lived in Van we would be arguing the other way around

Sure, if I let the passion for my hometown team blind me.

 

[DEVILS ALL THE WAY*]

From the same guy who said that the Devils would trade Scott Gomez for Brad Winchester...

The Devils should go for Mikhnov instead of Winchester !!!!

 

[Traktor*]

The Devils should go for Mikhnov instead of Winchester !!!!

Mikhnov is untouchable..

 

[Traktor*]

Sure, if I let the passion for my hometown team blind me.

But I thought thats what you were already doing..

 

[RayLeeCharles]

Because stats are everything in the CHL? Look who Brule played with - Mitch Bartley and Spencet Machacek. Two players who may never be professionals. Brule SINGLE HANDEDLY dominated the WHL like we haven't seen in recent memory.

'' ''

'' ''

He didnt just dominate the WHL, but look at his body of work at the Memorial Cup. He was the best player at that tournament hands down. Hes the best forward prospect in my eyes following Malkin. I cant say Ill miss him beating up on Spokane like he did but he was sure fun to watch.

 

[Bulldog]

Canucks potential sniper...Jesse Schulz.

 

[Canucks_Reloaded]

luc bourdon should be a contender for it

 

[aspin]

Kostitsyn > Schremp

Pouliot > Kostitsyn

The stats don't lie man. It was Pouliot's first year in the AHL and he was better than Kos on the same team. Hard to argue that.

 

[aspin]

Yep, they act like he'll be in the freaking ECHL or something. IMO he should be getting the same kind of clout that fellow CHL dominators like Wolski and Radulov have been getting.

The thing that goes against Schremp is that the Oilers are so so deep at forward that he is most likely not going to get a chance to play in the top 6. Also it is also up in the air if he even makes the team because they have so many good prospects with more experience (Thoresen and Pouliot).

 

[aspin]

I will throw Thoresen out there. He put up some really great stats in the QMJHL and most recently SEL. It will be a dogfight between him, Pouliot and Schremp to see who makes the 3rd Centre position this year. If Mikhnov comes over I think he has a good shot. If Schremp or Pouliot were on a team where they would get top 6 minutes I would like there chances a lot.

 

[dabid]

Sidney Crosby.

 

[LUONGO]

For the Canucks, Luc Bourdon could make a stab for it.

agreed, i don't understand why he isn't getting the amount attention that toivenen and brule are gettin he should be able to at least compete for the calder

 

[Jaded-Fan]

If it is true as rumored that Malkin has signed another contract, then why is there any speculation left about what his status will be for next season? If his RSL club was willing to void his initial deal for one more year with him, then they're going to get one more year with him. It's pretty cut and dry.

If they tore up his contract and he signed another one, then which means more his actions or his words? Malkin is saying the right things to not alienate his fans in Pittsburgh, but his actions are indicative of a person more torn about coming over to the NHL next year.

Can I say I told you all so now?

 

[Puckz]

Pouliot > Kostitsyn

The stats don't lie man. It was Pouliot's first year in the AHL and he was better than Kos on the same team. Hard to argue that.

Sorry, not sure if you're being sarcastic or not, so no offence... but if you are going by stats then Kostitsyn outproduced Pouliot in both the AHL and NHL.

 

[Skyblaze]

Don't be silly, Kostitsyn has very poor chances of winning the Calder. Barring injuries, he's likely to spend most of the season in Hamilton.

I wonder if Matt Carle is still eligible, he might have a good season.

My out-of-left-field prediction for the Calder : Braydon Coburn

 

[kmad]

Sidney Crosby.

Ovechkin!