Whalers Fan
Go Habs!
From my experience the leg room is roughly the same, but the seats feel WAY thinner, meaning you are basically having to lean forward to keep from rubbing your elbows against the person sitting next to you.
I sat in the upper bowl for one preseason game last year, and there was absolutely no leg room -- I could not move my legs or feet at all. My legs actually began to cramp up after about 15-20 minutes, and I'm only 5'9" tall. At least in JLA I could move my legs. It's inexcusable for a brand new arena. I'm not a Wings fan (go Habs), so I usually only go to games when Montreal comes to town. Therefore, it's not a big deal to me -- I'll just watch the games at home on my 70-inch display, sitting in my nice comfortable recliner, drinking a quality micro brew for a fraction of Crappy Pizza Arena prices, and with a great free parking spot in my garage. That beats spending $200+ for two seats in the sardine can upper bowl with parking and a couple of beers for my wife and me.
I have a friend, though, who's a diehard Wings fan and had been a season ticket holder for about 25 years in the upper bowl in JLA -- he's on a budget, so tried to do things as inexpensively as possible. He was so disgusted by the new seats that he sold his tickets to any game he could last season and did not renew this year -- something that I never would have expected to see from him. He said he wasn't going to spend that much money to be that uncomfortable.
The more expensive lower bowl seats and concourse areas were very nice, but whoever designed the upper bowl seating should be sued.