I agree that Jake is our most skilled winger but I just don't see him thrive on the left side. Berube has already briefly tried him there earlier this season when nothing else would click and he looked lost out there.
If possible, they should avoid having players play out of their natural position.
Brayden Schenn is a natural center but he has also shown some promise when used as a LW. That's fine and leads to more options in regard to the lineup. i just wanted to raise the question why both Voracek and Schenn should be asked to play out of position?
You seem to be convinced putting together a Voracek/G/Schenn line would create a superior first line but other than your personal observations and the fact that all three are very talented players there is no evidence for that assumption. No offense! Just my two cents...
Well naturally no, you wouldn't expect a RW to thrive on the left wing. But we don't have the pieces there, Hartnell being our only "natural" top 9 winger. I was suggesting that looks like his skillset would be able to soften the blow if you will with more efficiency than anyone else being shoved over there. I would take the results of line tinkering from the beginning of this season with a grain of salt and Im sure anyone could assume why, no? The whole team was lost being in an arena to begin with.
Im not 100% convinced that trio would be the one that does it for us ... But I suggested this same thing a while back when G/Jake were on a tear that it was only a matter of time until they were ice cold at ES and here we are again, ofcourse. Those 2 simply don't have good natural chemistry the way theyre sitting.
Brayden has shown some promise on the Left side you're right, but he was stuck there and he's got plenty of skill to make use of wherever he's but but is lacking that outside speed (which is my most important point about Jake) you need to be more successful winger on your forehand especially in todays game, have you ever been in a game to realize this for yourself?
As I said, it'd be nice if we had any good left wingers but we don't so Im just putting forward my best argument for how to maximize the efficiency of the pieces that we do have regardless of their "natural" positions. Giroux's natural position is as a RW too, but as you can see....
We need to find some real pairs and/or combos with real chemistry or we're going to stick in mediocrity with what we have. G with Jake on the right aren't one of these pairs. The chem isn't there at the level im talking about and suggesting it needs to be at as our go-to guys.
I guess for the record so that there's no confusion I do feel that Schenn has slightly more potential on the RW than Jake does, and that Jake would blow Schenn outta the water off the left side. This is the basis of it all.
"Natural" Positions of our top-9'er guys:
C-Schenn, Couturier, Vinny
RW-Giroux, Voracek, Simmonds, Read, Downie
LW-Hartnell
Some things either gotta give or go, hopefully we find something that works atleast warm and not so hot and cold. Gs skill on the PP likely takes care of it from that point.