GDT: Let's Rock: Devils @ Capitals, 7 PM, MSG+

Status
Not open for further replies.

JimEIV

Registered User
Feb 19, 2003
66,033
28,372
Not sure if this is the goal that happens in the GDT at that point, but are people really blaming Severson for the second goal? It was a perfect scissor play, he really couldn't do anything. Butcher, on the other hand is puckwatching and loses Backstrom which makes that whole sequence possible. Kind of a typical example why you can't leave Butcher (yet) to play against top lines.
I have completely given up trying to dissect plays. People see what they want.
 

Richer's Ghost

Bourbonite
Apr 19, 2007
60,162
14,544
photoshop labor camp somewhere in MN
You can challenge any goal for offsides or goalie interference but you can't challenge any play for too many men? That makes so much sense. You should be able to challenge any play at any time for too many men, illegal equipment, kicking or batting the puck in goal, goalie interference, and puck out of play. Those all should be apparent to the War Room as well but we won't get into the sticking points of when Toronto can and should get involved in reviewing plays when the on-ice officials have that same ability.

And get rid of the offsides review all together - it's stupid. Go to a system of max 2 challenges for any of the above where if you win the first challenge you keep your timeout and challenge a 2nd time. No penalty if wrong, just you lose your timeout and can't challenge a 2nd time. Teams shouldn't be punished for fixing an officiating wrong by losing the timeout or the ability to fix a 2nd mistake also later in the game. It's screwy that getting something corrected has a negative impact to you after the fact.
 
  • Like
Reactions: glenwo2

Blender

Registered User
Dec 2, 2009
51,383
45,278
You can challenge any goal for offsides or goalie interference but you can't challenge any play for too many men? That makes so much sense. You should be able to challenge any play at any time for too many men, illegal equipment, kicking or batting the puck in goal, goalie interference, and puck out of play. Those all should be apparent to the War Room as well but we won't get into the sticking points of when Toronto can and should get involved in reviewing plays when the on-ice officials have that same ability.

And get rid of the offsides review all together - it's stupid. Go to a system of max 2 challenges for any of the above where if you win the first challenge you keep your timeout and challenge a 2nd time. No penalty if wrong, just you lose your timeout and can't challenge a 2nd time. Teams shouldn't be punished for fixing an officiating wrong by losing the timeout or the ability to fix a 2nd mistake also later in the game. It's screwy that getting something corrected has a negative impact to you after the fact.
...but Matt Duchene was offside by many feet and it was all over sportscenter, so they put in an offside challenge.

This has never had anything to do with getting the calls right.
 

Tretyak 20

Registered User
Dec 4, 2003
4,153
1,341
Visit site
Not sure if this is the goal that happens in the GDT at that point, but are people really blaming Severson for the second goal? It was a perfect scissor play, he really couldn't do anything. Butcher, on the other hand is puckwatching and loses Backstrom which makes that whole sequence possible. Kind of a typical example why you can't leave Butcher (yet) to play against top lines.

The thing I really didn't like on the 2nd goal was Zajac. First he gets totally left behind on the play, then signals for a change, then inexplicably starts candy-assing his was back towards the zone and is still about fifty feet away when the goal is scored.
 

VaxjoDevil

No kids - Still a person
Nov 11, 2009
8,955
471
Princeton, NJ
The thing I really didn't like on the 2nd goal was Zajac. First he gets totally left behind on the play, then signals for a change, then inexplicably starts candy-assing his was back towards the zone and is still about fifty feet away when the goal is scored.

Yeah it was definitely a 3 on 2 so the third man high from our zone was not doing his job whoever that was, most probably the center.
 

glenwo2

LINDY RUFF NEEDS VIAGRA!!
Oct 18, 2008
52,050
24,329
New Jersey(No Fanz!)
Washington is just a really bad matchup for us. Lets hope if we make the playoffs we stay away from them.

Didn't the Rags have a stretch at one point in a past season where they Dominated us in the regular season and then we turned the tables on them in the postseason?

Caps won't be able to win 4 straight against us. I think THAT series goes the full 7.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad