Lesser of 2 Evils: Carcillo vs. Mashinter

[CallMeShaft]

Assuming cap hits are the same which player do you prefer.

Note: Don't bother saying neither. We are all aware that this team would be better served without an enforcer. If Q and Bowman want an enforcer (which they do), one of these players will be on the roster.

Click to read more...

 

[No Fun Shogun]

Heh, not a bad idea....

I think I'd go with Carbomb.

 

[BobbyJet]

I want to see Mashinter in RS action before making that call, and Carcillo as well, for that matter. As BWC said, Carcillo looked like he may have lost a step after getting injured, and I haven't seen Mashinter play outside of the few games in pre-season.

 

[CallMeShaft]

I want to see Mashinter in RS action before making that call, and Carcillo as well, for that matter. As BWC said, Carcillo looked like he may have lost a step after getting injured, and I haven't seen Mashinter play outside of the few games in pre-season.

I did hear BWC's opinion on Carcillo. Have no idea what he has looked like myself (that should change tonight). If he has indeed lost a step, the choice may be more difficult. Tonight should be very telling in terms of who gets that spot.

 

[ClydeLee]

You have to go with the guy you know can actually play NHL Hockey.. even though you know he's prone to dumb decisions, he does have nhl caliber skill for a goon role.

 

[Hawkaholic]

Neither from what I have seen, but at least Mash doesn't have the bad rep and can fight with the best of them.

 

[Thucydides]

Carbomb. He'll chip in a few goals with limited minutes on the fourth line. All you can ask for.

 

[Mad Dog Madison]

I prefer neither, but if Q is going to continue to be dumbass and dress a worthless player over Morin, then it's better to have Carcillo. I hope the PK unit is ready to kill off a bunch of 5 minute boarding majors now.

 

[Crazy_Ike]

Sorry but I'm saying 'neither' anyways. They both suck. Carcillo has more years of sucking. Neither player should ever see the ice in the playoffs, in which case why bother having them at all.

 

[UsernameWasTaken]

Voted Carcillo b/c I had to pick one.

However, I haven't seen anything from any Q-proclaimed 'enforcer' the past few years that has made me believe, for a second, the team is better off with said player on the team.

Only someone with zero brain activity would honestly believe our 'stars' were protected last season by having Bollig around to keep the rats honest. Give your head a shake!

 

[Bubba88]

prefer Carcillo

he helped us to win a Cup or 2

 

[Sarava]

From what i've seen I'd rather have Mashinter....but he's hurt.

 

[zac]

Neither of them should be playing. This "role" that Q wants on the team has resulted in a lesser player having playing time/roster spot over a more talented player for the last 5 seasons (including this one). It's ****ing ridiculous.

 

[Kurtosis]

Carcillo was a terrible signing. Will be utilized terribly. Terrible all around. I refuse to vote because I hate both of them.

 

[ChiGuySez]

Mashinter is not an NHL player.

 

[SotasicA]

We are all aware that this team would be better served without an enforcer.

What?

And since when is Carcillo an enforcer anyway? Players like Carcillo are the reason you want an enforcer on your team.