Let me take a different approach -- although most of what I read here looks right to me. Babcock is a big part of the problem.
Before you attack what I am going to say, just think it over, but here it is -- same thing I said last summer: SIGNING TAVARES WAS A MISTAKE.
(DIDN'T FINISH.. .CONTINUING...)
This is not a matter of Tavares: he was great, stand-up guy, super talented. My point has nothing to do with Tavares per se, but THE INDIRECT CONSEQUENCES OF SIGNING TAVARES.
(sorry, KEEP HITTING ENTER BY MISTAKE.. TOO UPSET..)
Which include:
1) Did we gain in the standings? No.
2) Signing Tavares essentially shelved Kadri, who had scored over 30 goals the previous two seasons. A team can only score so many goals, because they only NEED to score so many goals. Center was not the main weakness of this team.
3) Three of the six defencemen on this team are questionable. Take that money and think about what you erally need on defense, one or two more big time shut- down defensemen.
4) Degrees of freedom --- a term from statistics. Signing Tavares reduces Dubas' degrees of freedom so drastically that I can only imagine the rest of the team being scrubs anyway after they sign Marner. Everyone note: how is it possible to have a cup winning team if three players take up over 40 million of cap space, or 4 players take up over 50 million. Sorry, I can't play defense -- I'm 71.
5) There are other holes on this team to think about: 4th line centre, bruising winger who scores. Better back-up goalie.
6) Tavares is a great player, but he is a robotic leader. I don't see the passion there, or the leadership, so I hope he wasn't signed to be the captain here. Did anyone notice the Islanders did better without him? He's too self-serious.
I could go on.... but this is about the dominoes that fall as a result of that signing, and the net-net long-term. Not good....