Phaneuf and Reimer at the top of the list. They have had an impact on every single game and used in the most key situations. It's not even a close race.
Lupul and Kadri are next on the list; who have been very consistent.
The Kessel, Fraser, and Franson. Kessel continues to put up points; Fraser and Franson have been steady.
You also have McClement, Kulemin, Komarov; who have really shored up the PK and forward defensive contribution.
I would be fine with any of those; but the real gem has been Carlyle.