No, it really doesn't. Marner might not be in the conversation, but it's not completely absurd to suggest maybe someday he'd be in on the Selke. Tavares definitely has a reputation as a solid defensive player, even if, again, he's not a selke candidate. If the Selke was given purely to defensive players, Hyman and Brown would definitely have the potential to be in the conversation at some point in their careers, if they aren't already. Kadri was being talked about as a potential Selke candidate just last year. And Matthews is definitely a potential strong candidate for a Selke at some point. Everyone else in our top nine, save maybe Marleau, are definitely people who should be winning Selkes. Nylander is flat out not. Not now, not ever, unless his defensive game completely changes. Worst of all, it shouldn't be a massive knock against him. Not all players are defensively sound. Nylander still brings necessary and high-quality skill to the team and has and will continue to be a key part of the Leafs, likely for a long time. He's just not good defensively, therefore he shouldn't be playing in the last 5 minutes. Period.