Lays top 170 for March-2019 draft rankings

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
Kakko has surpassed Hughes for me for the 2nd time this year. My list for this year seems to be settling, earlier this year I wasn’t confident of my 1st round and was always shuffling around players but lately it’s pretty compact. I don’t see much changing soon unless I’m blown away by a prospect. At this point I think I can give a good scouting report for any prospect in my top 100 and a few past that. Haven’t had as much time lately to watch games

Anyways,

  1. Kaapo Kakko
  2. Jack Hughes
  3. Kirby Dach
  4. Alex Turcotte
  5. Vasili Podkolzin
  6. Bowen Byram
  7. Peyton Krebs
  8. Alex Newhook
  9. Dylan Cozens
  10. Pavel Dorofeyev
  11. Trevor Zegras
  12. Victor Soderstrom
  13. Matthew Boldy
  14. Cole Caufield
  15. Philipp Tomasino
  16. Jakob Pelletier
  17. Cam York
  18. Arthur Kaliyev
  19. Nils Hoglander
  20. Moritz Seider
  21. Ville Heinola
  22. Matthew Robertson
  23. Thomas Harley
  24. Raphael Lavoie
  25. Ryan Suzuki
  26. Jamieson Rees
  27. Philipp Broberg
  28. Samuel Fagemo
  29. Ilya Nikolayev
  30. Connor McMichael
  31. Yegor Afanasyev
  32. Samuel Bolduc
  33. Mikko Kokkonen
  34. Nicholas Robertson
  35. Samuel Poulin
  36. Albin Grewe
  37. Nathan Legare
  38. Bobby Brink
  39. Tobias Bjornfot
  40. Michal Teply
  41. Ryder Donovan
  42. Yegor Spiridonov
  43. Brett Leason
  44. Roman Bychkov
  45. Maxim Cajkovic
  46. Vladislav Kolyachonok
  47. Lassi Thomson
  48. John Beecher
  49. Matias Maccelli
  50. Alex Vlasic
  51. Robert Mastrosimone
  52. Artemi Knyazev
  53. Kim Nousiainen
  54. Ryan Johnson
  55. Nikola Pasic
  56. Nolan Foote
  57. Graeme Clarke
  58. Simon Holmstrom
  59. Anttoni Honka
  60. Kaedan Korczak
  61. Alex Beaucage
  62. Matvei Guskov
  63. Patrik Puistola
  64. Justin Bergeron
  65. Daniil Gutik
  66. Henri Thrun
  67. Simon Lundmark
  68. Dmitri Sheshin
  69. Cole Moberg
  70. Antti Tuomisto
  71. Michael Vukojevic
  72. Billy Constantinou
  73. Tuukka Tieksola
  74. Harrison Blaisdell
  75. Blake Murray
  76. Dillon Hamaliuk
  77. Cole Schwindt
  78. Sasha Mutala
  79. Henri Nikkanen
  80. Joe Carroll
  81. Lucas Feuk
  82. Marshall Warren
  83. Daniil Misyul
  84. Yegor Serdyuk
  85. Liam Ross
  86. Valeri Orekhov
  87. Kalle Loponen
  88. Alex Campbell
  89. Adam Beckman
  90. Luke Toporowski
  91. Brayden Tracey
  92. Oleg Zaitsev
  93. Martin Hugo Has
  94. Case McCarthy
  95. Ben Brinkman
  96. Leevi Aaltonen
  97. Petr Cajka
  98. Nikita Alexandrov
  99. Valentin Nussbaumer
  100. Vladislav Firstov
  101. Mathieu Bizier
  102. Shane Pinto
  103. John Farinacci
  104. Ethan Keppen
  105. Iaroslav Likhachev
  106. Drew Helleson
  107. Jake Lee
  108. Brady Meyer
  109. Mitchell Brewer
  110. Karl Henriksson
  111. Xavier Simoneau
  112. Nicholas Porco
  113. Marcus Kallionkieli
  114. Elmer Soderblom
  115. Keean Washkurak
  116. Gianni Fairbrother
  117. Trevor Janicke
  118. Kirill Slepets
  119. John Malone
  120. Georgiy Ivanov
  121. Carter Berger
  122. Ilya Mironov
  123. Josh Nodler
  124. Quinn Schmiemann
  125. Josh Williams
  126. Antti Saarela
  127. Mikhail Abramov
  128. Matthew Steinburg
  129. Rhett Pitlick
  130. Zac Jones
  131. Brett Budgell
  132. Jordan Spence
  133. Patrick Moynihan
  134. Martin Lang
  135. Bryce Brodzinski
  136. Logan Barlage
  137. Maxim Shabanov
  138. Judd Caulfield
  139. Anthony Romano
  140. Reece Newkirk
  141. Andrei Pribylskiy
  142. Matias Mantikivi
  143. Albin Sundsvik
  144. Christopher Merisier-Ortiz
  145. Grant Silianoff
  146. Kristian Tanus
  147. Layton Ahac
  148. Marcel Barinka
  149. Max Guenette
  150. Jacob LeGuerrier
  151. Daniel D’Amico
  152. Vojtech Strondala
  153. Alex Gordin
  154. Nikita Okhotyuk
  155. Albert Johansson
  156. Cole Mackay
  157. Vladimir Alistrov
  158. Max Wahlgren
  159. Brooklyn Kalmikov
  160. Semyon Chistyakov
  161. Alexei Protas
  162. Mason Primeau
  163. Massimo Rizzo
  164. Anthony Imbeault
  165. Artem Galimov
  166. Xavier Parent
  167. Jacob Winterton
  168. Wiljami Myllyla
  169. Jack York
  170. Arvid Costmar
Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Mildan

Dominance

99-66-4-9-87/97
Sep 30, 2017
7,843
12,334
The Land of Hockey
Outstanding list! I really like the composition of your first round. I was going to comment that I’d have Cozens higher, but honestly 1-2 and your 3-9 are really getting to be freely interchangeable, although Byram has solidified his claim to the third slot for me.

I’ve seen people suggesting that this draft class has bad depth, but I don’t get it. Maybe not all-time great but as stated above, there’s a solid 10-strong group (add Dorofeyev or Soderstrom into the 9 mentioned above) that I think are truly elite prospects, and being able to pick a guy like McMichael at the end of the first round is pretty incredible to me.
 

emptyNedder

Not seeking rents
Sponsor
Jan 17, 2018
3,808
8,573
Wondering what you see in Graeme Clarke. Central Scouting has him at 56 for NA, which equates to 75-80. Most other rankings I have seen have him 90 or lower. From the clips I have seen he has flashy puck skills, but seem really inconsistent.
 

16thOverallSaveUs

Danila Yurov Fan Club Executive Assistant
May 2, 2018
18,737
11,725
Kakko has surpassed Hughes for me for the 2nd time this year. My list for this year seems to be settling, earlier this year I wasn’t confident of my 1st round and was always shuffling around players but lately it’s pretty compact. I don’t see much changing soon unless I’m blown away by a prospect. At this point I think I can give a good scouting report for any prospect in my top 100 and a few past that. Haven’t had as much time lately to watch games

Anyways,

  1. Kaapo Kakko
  2. Jack Hughes
  3. Kirby Dach
  4. Alex Turcotte
  5. Vasili Podkolzin
  6. Bowen Byram
  7. Peyton Krebs
  8. Alex Newhook
  9. Dylan Cozens
  10. Pavel Dorofeyev
  11. Trevor Zegras
  12. Victor Soderstrom
  13. Matthew Boldy
  14. Cole Caufield
  15. Philipp Tomasino
  16. Jakob Pelletier
  17. Cam York
  18. Arthur Kaliyev
  19. Nils Hoglander
  20. Moritz Seider
  21. Ville Heinola
  22. Matthew Robertson
  23. Thomas Harley
  24. Raphael Lavoie
  25. Ryan Suzuki
  26. Jamieson Rees
  27. Philipp Broberg
  28. Samuel Fagemo
  29. Ilya Nikolayev
  30. Connor McMichael
  31. Yegor Afanasyev
  32. Samuel Bolduc
  33. Mikko Kokkonen
  34. Nicholas Robertson
  35. Samuel Poulin
  36. Albin Grewe
  37. Nathan Legare
  38. Bobby Brink
  39. Tobias Bjornfot
  40. Michal Teply
  41. Ryan Donovan
  42. Yegor Spiridonov
  43. Brett Leason
  44. Roman Bychkov
  45. Maxim Cajkovic
  46. Vladislav Kolyachonok
  47. Lassi Thomson
  48. John Beecher
  49. Matias Maccelli
  50. Alex Vlasic
  51. Robert Mastrosimone
  52. Artemi Knyazev
  53. Kim Nousiainen
  54. Ryan Johnson
  55. Nikola Pasic
  56. Nolan Foote
  57. Graeme Clarke
  58. Simon Holmstrom
  59. Anttoni Honka
  60. Kaedan Korczak
  61. Alex Beaucage
  62. Matvei Guskov
  63. Patrik Puistola
  64. Justin Bergeron
  65. Daniil Gutik
  66. Henri Thrun
  67. Simon Lundmark
  68. Dmitri Sheshin
  69. Cole Moberg
  70. Antti Tuomisto
  71. Michael Vukojevic
  72. Billy Constantinou
  73. Tuukka Tieksola
  74. Harrison Blaisdell
  75. Blake Murray
  76. Dillon Hamaliuk
  77. Cole Schwindt
  78. Sasha Mutala
  79. Henri Nikkanen
  80. Joe Carroll
  81. Lucas Feuk
  82. Marshall Warren
  83. Yegor Serdyuk
  84. Liam Ross
  85. Valeri Orekhov
  86. Kalle Loponen
  87. Alex Campbell
  88. Adam Beckman
  89. Luke Toporowski
  90. Brayden Tracey
  91. Oleg Zaitsev
  92. Martin Hugo Has
  93. Case McCarthy
  94. Ben Brinkman
  95. Leevi Aaltonen
  96. Petr Cajka
  97. Nikita Alexandrov
  98. Valentin Nussbaumer
  99. Vladislav Firstov
  100. Mathieu Bizier
  101. Shane Pinto
  102. John Farinacci
  103. Ethan Keppen
  104. Iaroslav Likhachev
  105. Drew Helleson
  106. Jake Lee
  107. Brady Meyer
  108. Mitchell Brewer
  109. Karl Henriksson
  110. Xavier Simoneau
  111. Nicholas Porco
  112. Marcus Kallionkieli
  113. Elmer Soderblom
  114. Keean Washkurak
  115. Gianni Fairbrother
  116. Trevor Janicke
  117. Kirill Slepets
  118. John Malone
  119. Georgiy Ivanov
  120. Carter Berger
  121. Ilya Mironov
  122. Josh Nodler
  123. Quinn Schmiemann
  124. Josh Williams
  125. Antti Saarela
  126. Mikhail Abramov
  127. Matthew Steinburg
  128. Rhett Pitlick
  129. Zac Jones
  130. Brett Budgell
  131. Jordan Spence
  132. Patrick Moynihan
  133. Martin Lang
  134. Daniil Misyul
  135. Bryce Brodzinski
  136. Logan Barlage
  137. Maxim Shabanov
  138. Judd Caulfield
  139. Anthony Romano
  140. Reece Newkirk
  141. Andrei Pribylskiy
  142. Matias Mantikivi
  143. Albin Sundsvik
  144. Christopher Merisier-Ortiz
  145. Grant Silianoff
  146. Kristian Tanus
  147. Layton Ahac
  148. Marcel Barinka
  149. Max Guenette
  150. Jacob LeGuerrier
  151. Daniel D’Amico
  152. Vojtech Strondala
  153. Alex Gordin
  154. Nikita Okhotyuk
  155. Albert Johansson
  156. Cole Mackay
  157. Vladimir Alistrov
  158. Max Wahlgren
  159. Brooklyn Kalmikov
  160. Semyon Chistyakov
  161. Alexei Protas
  162. Mason Primeau
  163. Massimo Rizzo
  164. Anthony Imbeault
  165. Artem Galimov
  166. Xavier Parent
  167. Jacob Winterton
  168. Wiljami Myllyla
  169. Jack York
  170. Arvid Costmar
Thoughts?
I like your list a lot and like some of the players you have going later in the draft. My only question is: what has moved the needle on kakko for you? I know he’s having a great season, but I haven’t seen a single credible analyst list him over Hughes. I’m not saying that’s right, I’m just intrigued.
 

ConnorMcMullet

#12 Colby Cave
Jun 10, 2017
10,293
18,030
Kakko has surpassed Hughes for me for the 2nd time this year. My list for this year seems to be settling, earlier this year I wasn’t confident of my 1st round and was always shuffling around players but lately it’s pretty compact. I don’t see much changing soon unless I’m blown away by a prospect. At this point I think I can give a good scouting report for any prospect in my top 100 and a few past that. Haven’t had as much time lately to watch games

Anyways,

  1. Kaapo Kakko
  2. Jack Hughes
  3. Kirby Dach
  4. Alex Turcotte
  5. Vasili Podkolzin
  6. Bowen Byram
  7. Peyton Krebs
  8. Alex Newhook
  9. Dylan Cozens
  10. Pavel Dorofeyev
  11. Trevor Zegras
  12. Victor Soderstrom
  13. Matthew Boldy
  14. Cole Caufield
  15. Philipp Tomasino
  16. Jakob Pelletier
  17. Cam York
  18. Arthur Kaliyev
  19. Nils Hoglander
  20. Moritz Seider
  21. Ville Heinola
  22. Matthew Robertson
  23. Thomas Harley
  24. Raphael Lavoie
  25. Ryan Suzuki
  26. Jamieson Rees
  27. Philipp Broberg
  28. Samuel Fagemo
  29. Ilya Nikolayev
  30. Connor McMichael
  31. Yegor Afanasyev
  32. Samuel Bolduc
  33. Mikko Kokkonen
  34. Nicholas Robertson
  35. Samuel Poulin
  36. Albin Grewe
  37. Nathan Legare
  38. Bobby Brink
  39. Tobias Bjornfot
  40. Michal Teply
  41. Ryan Donovan
  42. Yegor Spiridonov
  43. Brett Leason
  44. Roman Bychkov
  45. Maxim Cajkovic
  46. Vladislav Kolyachonok
  47. Lassi Thomson
  48. John Beecher
  49. Matias Maccelli
  50. Alex Vlasic
  51. Robert Mastrosimone
  52. Artemi Knyazev
  53. Kim Nousiainen
  54. Ryan Johnson
  55. Nikola Pasic
  56. Nolan Foote
  57. Graeme Clarke
  58. Simon Holmstrom
  59. Anttoni Honka
  60. Kaedan Korczak
  61. Alex Beaucage
  62. Matvei Guskov
  63. Patrik Puistola
  64. Justin Bergeron
  65. Daniil Gutik
  66. Henri Thrun
  67. Simon Lundmark
  68. Dmitri Sheshin
  69. Cole Moberg
  70. Antti Tuomisto
  71. Michael Vukojevic
  72. Billy Constantinou
  73. Tuukka Tieksola
  74. Harrison Blaisdell
  75. Blake Murray
  76. Dillon Hamaliuk
  77. Cole Schwindt
  78. Sasha Mutala
  79. Henri Nikkanen
  80. Joe Carroll
  81. Lucas Feuk
  82. Marshall Warren
  83. Yegor Serdyuk
  84. Liam Ross
  85. Valeri Orekhov
  86. Kalle Loponen
  87. Alex Campbell
  88. Adam Beckman
  89. Luke Toporowski
  90. Brayden Tracey
  91. Oleg Zaitsev
  92. Martin Hugo Has
  93. Case McCarthy
  94. Ben Brinkman
  95. Leevi Aaltonen
  96. Petr Cajka
  97. Nikita Alexandrov
  98. Valentin Nussbaumer
  99. Vladislav Firstov
  100. Mathieu Bizier
  101. Shane Pinto
  102. John Farinacci
  103. Ethan Keppen
  104. Iaroslav Likhachev
  105. Drew Helleson
  106. Jake Lee
  107. Brady Meyer
  108. Mitchell Brewer
  109. Karl Henriksson
  110. Xavier Simoneau
  111. Nicholas Porco
  112. Marcus Kallionkieli
  113. Elmer Soderblom
  114. Keean Washkurak
  115. Gianni Fairbrother
  116. Trevor Janicke
  117. Kirill Slepets
  118. John Malone
  119. Georgiy Ivanov
  120. Carter Berger
  121. Ilya Mironov
  122. Josh Nodler
  123. Quinn Schmiemann
  124. Josh Williams
  125. Antti Saarela
  126. Mikhail Abramov
  127. Matthew Steinburg
  128. Rhett Pitlick
  129. Zac Jones
  130. Brett Budgell
  131. Jordan Spence
  132. Patrick Moynihan
  133. Martin Lang
  134. Daniil Misyul
  135. Bryce Brodzinski
  136. Logan Barlage
  137. Maxim Shabanov
  138. Judd Caulfield
  139. Anthony Romano
  140. Reece Newkirk
  141. Andrei Pribylskiy
  142. Matias Mantikivi
  143. Albin Sundsvik
  144. Christopher Merisier-Ortiz
  145. Grant Silianoff
  146. Kristian Tanus
  147. Layton Ahac
  148. Marcel Barinka
  149. Max Guenette
  150. Jacob LeGuerrier
  151. Daniel D’Amico
  152. Vojtech Strondala
  153. Alex Gordin
  154. Nikita Okhotyuk
  155. Albert Johansson
  156. Cole Mackay
  157. Vladimir Alistrov
  158. Max Wahlgren
  159. Brooklyn Kalmikov
  160. Semyon Chistyakov
  161. Alexei Protas
  162. Mason Primeau
  163. Massimo Rizzo
  164. Anthony Imbeault
  165. Artem Galimov
  166. Xavier Parent
  167. Jacob Winterton
  168. Wiljami Myllyla
  169. Jack York
  170. Arvid Costmar
Thoughts?
I really like this list. Only thing that stands out to me is McMichael seems pretty low.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GrittyHawkDown

Dominance

99-66-4-9-87/97
Sep 30, 2017
7,843
12,334
The Land of Hockey
I really like this list. Only thing that stands out to me is McMichael seems pretty low.
He’s tapered off a bit since his long hot stretch that had me certain he would break into the top-10, but I agree that he should be in the 15-20 range.

Who to bump down, though? It’s getting to the time of year where that question is a lot harder to answer. For me, the easy answer is to slide him in front of Kaliyev. McMichael’s a pretty great goal scorer in his own right, and not so reliant on a single spot on the powerplay. He’s also good to great in all of the areas that are concerns with Kaliyev. I know if I’m picking in that spot, as a team that just stayed afloat the playoff race, I’m taking the sure-fire middle-6er with considerable top-6 upside over wildly swinging at a potential home run.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16thOverallSaveUs

Get North

Registered User
Aug 25, 2013
8,472
1,364
B.C.
Once again, I don't know how Poulin isn't ranked in the top 15, he's on par with Boldy and Krebs, much better player than Kaliyev. He's wearing an A for his team in his 2nd year, that already tells you everything about the kids character and work ethic. Pelletier is a fair ranking, but seeing Poulin almost 20 picks away is just wrong.

Harley is 2nd best dman in the draft.

Newkirk, Keppen, Fairbrother should also be higher. Skill players with a lot of heart and grit are rare breeds nowadays.
 

57special

Posting the right way since 2012.
Sep 5, 2012
47,948
19,674
MN
Just talking about what I know, here. Brink is pretty low on your list, compared to others. What he is doing as a 17yo in the USHL is pretty crazy. Leads in PPG, USNDP guys aside.

Not a big deal, but Brodzinski and Pitlick should be flipped, at the very least. Pitlick has great skill and speed, but Brodzinski has speed, a shot, skill, and is already 6'1", 200lb. He also played a harder schedule, outpointed Pitlick by a good bit, and won "Mr. Hockey" for best MN player.

I don't know what to make of Brinkman. NCAA is a better league than the USHL, which is better than MNHS. I know Brinkman didn't produce much with the Gophers, but he looked solid, and I can't help but feel that he would've destroyed MNHS if he had stayed this year. I'll be curious to see how he pans out next year. I don't know that I can argue with your ranking of him...but him being the youngest player in college has to count for something.
 

UNITEDSTATESOFHOCKEY

Registered User
Jan 5, 2018
360
146
Just talking about what I know, here. Brink is pretty low on your list, compared to others. What he is doing as a 17yo in the USHL is pretty crazy. Leads in PPG, USNDP guys aside.

Not a big deal, but Brodzinski and Pitlick should be flipped, at the very least. Pitlick has great skill and speed, but Brodzinski has speed, a shot, skill, and is already 6'1", 200lb. He also played a harder schedule, outpointed Pitlick by a good bit, and won "Mr. Hockey" for best MN player.

I don't know what to make of Brinkman. NCAA is a better league than the USHL, which is better than MNHS. I know Brinkman didn't produce much with the Gophers, but he looked solid, and I can't help but feel that he would've destroyed MNHS if he had stayed this year. I'll be curious to see how he pans out next year. I don't know that I can argue with your ranking of him...but him being the youngest player in college has to count for something.

I agree with you on Brinkman... I think he'd be among the point leaders for defenseman in the USHL this year and probably would have won Mr. Hockey had he played High School.

I disagree on Brodzinski, he can't skate good enough for me, he has a shot but I think he's a bottom 6 forward if he ends up making it to the NHL at all.... i'm sure some team will grab him but i don't think it will be very high....
 

57special

Posting the right way since 2012.
Sep 5, 2012
47,948
19,674
MN
I agree with you on Brinkman... I think he'd be among the point leaders for defenseman in the USHL this year and probably would have won Mr. Hockey had he played High School.

I disagree on Brodzinski, he can't skate good enough for me, he has a shot but I think he's a bottom 6 forward if he ends up making it to the NHL at all.... i'm sure some team will grab him but i don't think it will be very high....
I was impressed by BB's speed. Edgework I didn't pay too much attention to. Isn't Koster (same team as Pitlick) a 2019, or is he an overager? If the former, he might be worth noting.

This is kind of obscure stuff, I know, and probably of little interest to most out there.
 

UNITEDSTATESOFHOCKEY

Registered User
Jan 5, 2018
360
146
I was impressed by BB's speed. Edgework I didn't pay too much attention to. Isn't Koster (same team as Pitlick) a 2019, or is he an overager? If the former, he might be worth noting.

This is kind of obscure stuff, I know, and probably of little interest to most out there.

He looks fast in High School, not so much in USHL, I think he will be a good college player for Minneosota tho.... pitlick and koster are both 2019's, not overagers... I'm not sure koster has the brain but he has some physical tools that are eye catching...
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
Wondering what you see in Graeme Clarke. Central Scouting has him at 56 for NA, which equates to 75-80. Most other rankings I have seen have him 90 or lower. From the clips I have seen he has flashy puck skills, but seem really inconsistent.
I know a lot won’t agree with this but I think Clark is a smart player. Always knows where to be and where to pass to. Great stick handler and a wicked shot. He has a lot to work on such as skating and consistency but if he can put it together his tools suggest a complimentary top winger. He’s not a safe pick but an enticing one
I like your list a lot and like some of the players you have going later in the draft. My only question is: what has moved the needle on kakko for you? I know he’s having a great season, but I haven’t seen a single credible analyst list him over Hughes. I’m not saying that’s right, I’m just intrigued.
Can’t really explain it but I see Kakko translating a bit better. I do think Hughes will translate just fine but he turns the puck over a lot and I think he’ll have to simplify his game a bit. It’s not a specific thing that happened to make me move Kakko to 1 it’s just it was a feeling I’ve had for a while, Kakko has seriously impressed me as of late while Hughes hasn’t elevated his game
Once again, I don't know how Poulin isn't ranked in the top 15, he's on par with Boldy and Krebs, much better player than Kaliyev. He's wearing an A for his team in his 2nd year, that already tells you everything about the kids character and work ethic. Pelletier is a fair ranking, but seeing Poulin almost 20 picks away is just wrong.

Harley is 2nd best dman in the draft.

Newkirk, Keppen, Fairbrother should also be higher. Skill players with a lot of heart and grit are rare breeds nowadays.
Poulin doesn’t have the offensive upside to be top 15. He’s definitely not close to Boldy or Krebs right now. I don’t agree that Harley is the 2nd best either, I’ve said it before but his defensive effort and his lack of dynamic offensive ability scare me a bit. He’s a great puck mover but his IQ has been lacking in my viewings. He does have good tools though
Just talking about what I know, here. Brink is pretty low on your list, compared to others. What he is doing as a 17yo in the USHL is pretty crazy. Leads in PPG, USNDP guys aside.

Not a big deal, but Brodzinski and Pitlick should be flipped, at the very least. Pitlick has great skill and speed, but Brodzinski has speed, a shot, skill, and is already 6'1", 200lb. He also played a harder schedule, outpointed Pitlick by a good bit, and won "Mr. Hockey" for best MN player.

I don't know what to make of Brinkman. NCAA is a better league than the USHL, which is better than MNHS. I know Brinkman didn't produce much with the Gophers, but he looked solid, and I can't help but feel that he would've destroyed MNHS if he had stayed this year. I'll be curious to see how he pans out next year. I don't know that I can argue with your ranking of him...but him being the youngest player in college has to count for something.
Brodzinski and Pitlick are newer additions to my list so that may explain their ranking. I’ve only seen one game of each and I’m basing that ranking over what I’ve seen and read of those two. I don’t think Brodzinski has Pitlick’s offensive upside though. I’m looking to catch more games of them though and hopefully will soon
Who's Ryan Donovan?!?
Meant to put Ryder Donovan, must be auto correct. Got his name right on my other lists lol
 

CheckingLineCenter

Registered User
Aug 10, 2018
8,298
8,823
Haven’t seen Fagemo > Leason too often... don’t necessarily disagree though. In your opinion, who arrives in the NHL sooner between those two?
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
No Leufvenius?
I think I like him better than most but nope
Haven’t seen Fagemo > Leason too often... don’t necessarily disagree though. In your opinion, who arrives in the NHL sooner between those two?
I think they have the same arrival date, after next year. I don’t recall Fagemo’s plans for next season but if he goes the AHL him and Leason have chances to get callups for a few games
 

Shmookpup

Registered User
Aug 8, 2016
47
33
I was surprised to see Bolduc at 32, what's the rationale behind him being that high? I don't disagree that he's in the B-level prospect range, just a little surprised to see him be the very first pick of the 2nd round
 

Get North

Registered User
Aug 25, 2013
8,472
1,364
B.C.
Poulin doesn’t have the offensive upside to be top 15. He’s definitely not close to Boldy or Krebs right now. I don’t agree that Harley is the 2nd best either, I’ve said it before but his defensive effort and his lack of dynamic offensive ability scare me a bit. He’s a great puck mover but his IQ has been lacking in my viewings. He does have good tools though
We see different players. I don't think Boldy and Krebs are anything special with their hands and dynamic offensive ability. They just make a lot of super smart plays with the puck and are strong skaters. Poulin has better hands than Boldy and Krebs IMO, he can be more dangerous if he reaches his ceiling. I don't see how he lacks the offensive upside those players do, production and pedigree is all there. Leads his team in scoring by over 10 points.
 

Dominance

99-66-4-9-87/97
Sep 30, 2017
7,843
12,334
The Land of Hockey
We see different players. I don't think Boldy and Krebs are anything special with their hands and dynamic offensive ability. They just make a lot of super smart plays with the puck and are strong skaters. Poulin has better hands than Boldy and Krebs IMO, he can be more dangerous if he reaches his ceiling. I don't see how he lacks the offensive upside those players do, production and pedigree is all there. Leads his team in scoring by over 10 points.
I like Poulin. I think he should sit in the last third of the first round for everyone right now, and he has potential going forward.

That said, he and Boldy have pretty similar tools - maybe a couple edges one way, and another few the other. But Poulin’s higher level of aggression doesn’t overcome the IQ/vision gap that has Boldy in the 10-15 tier. Krebs is a completely different animal but is just the significantly superior player in such a vast number of areas. He’s in the 5-10 tier.

The gaps between Poulin and these guys aren’t monumental, but they are very clearly present.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad