Lays 2019 Final Draft Rankings

CheckingLineCenter

Registered User
Aug 10, 2018
8,307
8,839
A bit above where I would maybe would have him but I like that you have Broberg high.

Conversely, why so low on Nick Robertson?
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
Snoozing on ohl's 51 goal scorer Arthur Kaliyev?

And a great list you have. :handclap:
Compete level is a big thing I look for and Kailyev’s isn’t there. Still has great upside though and his playmaking ability is underrated. He follows me on Instagram as well which is pretty cool
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
A bit above where I would maybe would have him but I like that you have Broberg high.

Conversely, why so low on Nick Robertson?
I’m not sure what Robertson is at the next level, he’s a tough player to rank for me. I come away impressed with every viewing though, he’s a guy that can absolutely break out next year
 
  • Like
Reactions: CheckingLineCenter

S E P H

Cloud IX
Mar 5, 2010
30,895
16,378
Toruń, PL
Could you go in depth with the Tomasino ranking because I don’t see it at 11th overall? He is a 3rd line player for me.
 

sting101

Registered User
Feb 8, 2012
15,859
14,699
Good read.

I think your summary of Cozens is pretty much what i watched live this year. I think his package will see him go higher and i do believe he will be smarter than Puljujarvi when it comes time to adjust his game but your reasoning is rock solid as it is on all the WHL guys based on what they have shown to date for that matter. Watching Dach at near ice level a few times this year was impressive. Incredibly smart IceQ

I also agree on Broberg. When is the last time we saw a player with those kind of skills with that physical package compete and skating not put it together and be an impact player? He's obviously looked a little like a dear in the headlights at 17 trying to sift through pro defenses and formations but i get the feeling with some seasoning a lot of teams will be regretting overlooking him if he falls into the teens. He's a upper level skater if he stepped in today......at worst he's a Darnell Nurse for me which is a pretty damn good player.

Any takes on Teply and Lundmark......a couple players im extremely high on based on their rankings?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mratch19 and Lays

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
Could you go in depth with the Tomasino ranking because I don’t see it at 11th overall? He is a 3rd line player for me.
What about him looks like a future 3rd liner? I see a potential top line RW in Tomasino

I said this in another post but he started off in the 80s but worked his way up to 11 for me, I’ve seen the most progression in Tomasino’s game than any other draft eligible prospect. He’s aggressive on the forecheck and is responsible defensively. His offensive game is well rounded, he’s a shoot first player and he gets his shot off so quickly, it already has power too. He has a high IQ as well and his playmaking is underrated, he can dish some nice sauces on either hand. His 5v5 production is also very good iirc. My only concern for him would be that he scores mostly off the rush, needs to have a better East-West game and I do see how that might make some people weary of his upside. I like that he slowly became a line driver over the course of the year though and also shot more
Good read.

I think your summary of Cozens is pretty much what i watched live this year. I think his package will see him go higher and i do believe he will be smarter than Puljujarvi when it comes time to adjust his game but your reasoning is rock solid as it is on all the WHL guys based on what they have shown to date for that matter. Watching Dach at near ice level a few times this year was impressive. Incredibly smart IceQ

I also agree on Broberg. When is the last time we saw a player with those kind of skills with that physical package compete and skating not put it together and be an impact player? He's obviously looked a little like a dear in the headlights at 17 trying to sift through pro defenses and formations but i get the feeling with some seasoning a lot of teams will be regretting overlooking him if he falls into the teens. He's a upper level skater if he stepped in today......at worst he's a Darnell Nurse for me which is a pretty damn good player.

Any takes on Teply and Lundmark......a couple players im extremely high on based on their rankings?
Teply had a bad second half and didn’t impress at tournaments. Don’t see much upside in him but I was a big fan of him early on. Good net front presence and has a good shot. Could maybe be a complimentary middle sixer

Lundmark is a pretty safe prospect, don’t see him as a top 4 but I think he can be a good fringe/bottom line defenseman. Nothing really stands out
 

FlameChampion

Registered User
Jul 13, 2011
13,647
15,256
I realized posting new rankings nearly every month was pointless. I’ve pretty much seen all I’ve needed to see and this list took a while to complete. I may add scouting reports for the top 62 and/or a mock draft later on and I’ll bump the thread if I do. Any questions/thoughts/feedback feel free comment

  1. Kaapo Kakko
  2. Jack Hughes
  3. Bowen Byram
  4. Alex Turcotte
  5. Kirby Dach
  6. Trevor Zegras
  7. Matthew Boldy
  8. Cole Caufield
  9. Philipp Broberg
  10. Vasili Podkolzin
  11. Philipp Tomasino
  12. Alex Newhook
  13. Peyton Krebs
  14. Cam York
  15. Egor Afanasyev
  16. Moritz Seider
  17. Thomas Harley
  18. Dylan Cozens
  19. Victor Soderstrom
  20. Arthur Kaliyev
  21. Pavel Dorofeyev
  22. Ville Heinola
  23. Patrik Puistola
  24. Vladislav Kolyachonok
  25. Raphael Lavoie
  26. Jamieson Rees
  27. Matthew Robertson
  28. Samuel Poulin
  29. Ilya Nikolayev
  30. Daniil Misyul
  31. Ryder Donovan
  32. Nils Hoglander
  33. Tobias Bjornfot
  34. Bobby Brink
  35. Connor McMichael
  36. Brett Leason
  37. Jakob Pelletier
  38. Ryan Suzuki
  39. Brayden Tracey
  40. Justin Bergeron
  41. Yegor Spiridonov
  42. Kaedan Korczak
  43. Samuel Bolduc
  44. Nicholas Robertson
  45. Lassi Thomson
  46. Nathan Legare
  47. Samuel Fagemo
  48. Maxim Cajkovic
  49. Robert Mastrosimone
  50. Albin Grewe
  51. Mikko Kokkonen
  52. Roman Bychkov
  53. John Beecher
  54. Mattias Maccelli
  55. Cole Moberg
  56. Vladislav Firstov
  57. Ethan Keppen
  58. Jack LaCombe
  59. Ryan Johnson
  60. Artemi Knyazev
  61. Zac Jones
  62. Ethan Phillips
  63. Antti Tuomisto
  64. Semyon Chistyakov
  65. Kim Nousiainen
  66. Alex Beaucage
  67. Alex Vlasic
  68. Adam Beckman
  69. Jayden Struble
  70. Dmitri Sheshin
  71. Matvei Guskov
  72. Ronnie Attard
  73. Simon Holmstrom
  74. Antti Saarela
  75. Nikita Alexandrov
  76. Michal Teply
  77. Henri Thrun
  78. Ryan Siedem
  79. Anttoni Honka
  80. Rhett Pitlick
  81. Elmer Soderblom
  82. Joe Carroll
  83. Nikola Pasic
  84. Daniil Gutik
  85. Nolan Foote
  86. John Farinacci
  87. Simon Lundmark
  88. Tuukka Tieksola
  89. Valeri Orekhov
  90. Oleg Zaitsev
  91. Jack Malone
  92. Santeria Hatakka
  93. Ben Brinkman
  94. Drew Helleson
  95. Mattias Norlinder
  96. Henry Rybinski
  97. Sasha Mutala
  98. Leevi Aaltonen
  99. Keean Washkurak
  100. Aaron Huglen
  101. Matthew Steinburg
  102. Bryce Brodzinski
  103. Case McCarthy
  104. Graeme Clark
  105. Martin Hugo Has
  106. Billy Constantinou
  107. Blake Murray
  108. Lucas Feuk
  109. Kalle Loponen
  110. Henri Nikkanen
  111. Albert Johansson
  112. Layton Ahac
  113. Shane Pinto
  114. Cole Schwindt
  115. Quinn Schmiemann
  116. Nicholas Porco
  117. Dillon Hamaliuk
  118. Kirill Slepets
  119. Max Crozier
  120. Lukas Rousek
  121. Liam Ross
  122. Trevor Janicke
  123. Michael Vukojevic
  124. Luke Toporowski
  125. Arseni Gritsyuk
  126. Daniil Ogirchuk
  127. Max Guenette
  128. Kristian Tanus
  129. Josh Nodler
  130. Braden Doyle
  131. Ondrej Psenicka
  132. Iaroslav Likhachev
  133. Mitchell Brewer
  134. Arvid Costmar
  135. Patrick Moynihan
  136. Gianni Fairbrother
  137. Marshall Warren
  138. Valentin Nussbaumer
  139. Harrison Blaisdell
  140. Mikhail Abramov
  141. Alexander Darin
  142. Garrett Pinoniemi
  143. Maxim Shabanov
  144. Cody Morgan
  145. Yegor Serdyuk
  146. Judd Caulfield
  147. Vladislav Mikhailov
  148. Alex Campbell
  149. Maxim Denezhkin
  150. Ludvig Hedstrom
  151. Matus Hlavac
  152. Kirill Tyutyayev
  153. Marcus Kallionkieli
  154. Petr Cajka
  155. Brady Meyer
  156. Jake Lee
  157. Karl Henriksson
  158. Mathieu Bizier
  159. Xavier Simoneau
  160. Ilya Mironov
  161. Adam Edstrom
  162. Alexei Protas
  163. Brett Budgell
  164. Carter Berger
  165. Reece Newkirk
  166. Jordan Spence
  167. Juuso Parssinen
  168. Nikita Rtischev
  169. Brayden Pachal
  170. Jeremie Bucheler
  171. Logan Barlage
  172. Anthony Romano
  173. Cole MacKay
  174. Andrei Pribylskiy
  175. Matias Mantikivi
  176. Samuel Sjolund
  177. Janis Moser
  178. Albin Sundsvik
  179. Christopher Merisier-Ortiz
  180. Grant Silianoff

I took Roman Bychkov in our draft mock board in round 7, but I dont know a whole lot about him. I see you have him fairly high at 52. What do you like about him?
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
I took Roman Bychkov in our draft mock board in round 7, but I dont know a whole lot about him. I see you have him fairly high at 52. What do you like about him?
I like that he’s aggressive defensively and is physical despite being 170 lbs, once he bulks up he’ll be very good in his own end. He also has high end speed and good IQ
 
  • Like
Reactions: FlameChampion

Sens of Anarchy

Registered User
Jul 9, 2013
65,233
49,838
I realized posting new rankings nearly every month was pointless. I’ve pretty much seen all I’ve needed to see and this list took a while to complete. I may add scouting reports for the top 62 and/or a mock draft later on and I’ll bump the thread if I do. Any questions/thoughts/feedback feel free comment

  1. Kaapo Kakko
  2. Jack Hughes
  3. Bowen Byram
  4. Alex Turcotte
  5. Kirby Dach
  6. Trevor Zegras
  7. Matthew Boldy
  8. Cole Caufield
  9. Philipp Broberg
  10. Vasili Podkolzin
  11. Philipp Tomasino
  12. Alex Newhook
  13. Peyton Krebs
  14. Cam York
  15. Egor Afanasyev
  16. Moritz Seider
  17. Thomas Harley
  18. Dylan Cozens
  19. Victor Soderstrom
  20. Arthur Kaliyev
  21. Pavel Dorofeyev
  22. Ville Heinola
  23. Patrik Puistola
  24. Vladislav Kolyachonok
  25. Raphael Lavoie
  26. Jamieson Rees
  27. Matthew Robertson
  28. Samuel Poulin
  29. Ilya Nikolayev
  30. Daniil Misyul
  31. Ryder Donovan
  32. Nils Hoglander
  33. Tobias Bjornfot
  34. Bobby Brink
  35. Connor McMichael
  36. Brett Leason
  37. Jakob Pelletier
  38. Ryan Suzuki
  39. Brayden Tracey
  40. Justin Bergeron
  41. Yegor Spiridonov
  42. Kaedan Korczak
  43. Samuel Bolduc
  44. Nicholas Robertson
  45. Lassi Thomson
  46. Nathan Legare
  47. Samuel Fagemo
  48. Maxim Cajkovic
  49. Robert Mastrosimone
  50. Albin Grewe
  51. Mikko Kokkonen
  52. Roman Bychkov
  53. John Beecher
  54. Mattias Maccelli
  55. Cole Moberg
  56. Vladislav Firstov
  57. Ethan Keppen
  58. Jack LaCombe
  59. Ryan Johnson
  60. Artemi Knyazev
  61. Zac Jones
  62. Ethan Phillips
  63. Antti Tuomisto
  64. Semyon Chistyakov
  65. Kim Nousiainen
  66. Alex Beaucage
  67. Alex Vlasic
  68. Adam Beckman
  69. Jayden Struble
  70. Dmitri Sheshin
  71. Matvei Guskov
  72. Ronnie Attard
  73. Simon Holmstrom
  74. Antti Saarela
  75. Nikita Alexandrov
  76. Michal Teply
  77. Henri Thrun
  78. Ryan Siedem
  79. Anttoni Honka
  80. Rhett Pitlick
  81. Elmer Soderblom
  82. Joe Carroll
  83. Nikola Pasic
  84. Daniil Gutik
  85. Nolan Foote
  86. John Farinacci
  87. Simon Lundmark
  88. Tuukka Tieksola
  89. Valeri Orekhov
  90. Oleg Zaitsev
  91. Jack Malone
  92. Santeria Hatakka
  93. Ben Brinkman
  94. Drew Helleson
  95. Mattias Norlinder
  96. Henry Rybinski
  97. Sasha Mutala
  98. Leevi Aaltonen
  99. Keean Washkurak
  100. Aaron Huglen
  101. Matthew Steinburg
  102. Bryce Brodzinski
  103. Case McCarthy
  104. Graeme Clark
  105. Martin Hugo Has
  106. Billy Constantinou
  107. Blake Murray
  108. Lucas Feuk
  109. Kalle Loponen
  110. Henri Nikkanen
  111. Albert Johansson
  112. Layton Ahac
  113. Shane Pinto
  114. Cole Schwindt
  115. Quinn Schmiemann
  116. Nicholas Porco
  117. Dillon Hamaliuk
  118. Kirill Slepets
  119. Max Crozier
  120. Lukas Rousek
  121. Liam Ross
  122. Trevor Janicke
  123. Michael Vukojevic
  124. Luke Toporowski
  125. Arseni Gritsyuk
  126. Daniil Ogirchuk
  127. Max Guenette
  128. Kristian Tanus
  129. Josh Nodler
  130. Braden Doyle
  131. Ondrej Psenicka
  132. Iaroslav Likhachev
  133. Mitchell Brewer
  134. Arvid Costmar
  135. Patrick Moynihan
  136. Gianni Fairbrother
  137. Marshall Warren
  138. Valentin Nussbaumer
  139. Harrison Blaisdell
  140. Mikhail Abramov
  141. Alexander Darin
  142. Garrett Pinoniemi
  143. Maxim Shabanov
  144. Cody Morgan
  145. Yegor Serdyuk
  146. Judd Caulfield
  147. Vladislav Mikhailov
  148. Alex Campbell
  149. Maxim Denezhkin
  150. Ludvig Hedstrom
  151. Matus Hlavac
  152. Kirill Tyutyayev
  153. Marcus Kallionkieli
  154. Petr Cajka
  155. Brady Meyer
  156. Jake Lee
  157. Karl Henriksson
  158. Mathieu Bizier
  159. Xavier Simoneau
  160. Ilya Mironov
  161. Adam Edstrom
  162. Alexei Protas
  163. Brett Budgell
  164. Carter Berger
  165. Reece Newkirk
  166. Jordan Spence
  167. Juuso Parssinen
  168. Nikita Rtischev
  169. Brayden Pachal
  170. Jeremie Bucheler
  171. Logan Barlage
  172. Anthony Romano
  173. Cole MacKay
  174. Andrei Pribylskiy
  175. Matias Mantikivi
  176. Samuel Sjolund
  177. Janis Moser
  178. Albin Sundsvik
  179. Christopher Merisier-Ortiz
  180. Grant Silianoff

I like Broberg in the top 10.
I think Tomasino is too high. Cozens is too low. I will bet you he goes top 10. Probably pushes Broberg down.
Not a huge Suzuki fan but he will go in the 1st
Afanasyev is too high and I am a fan.
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
I like Broberg in the top 10.
I think Tomasino is too high. Cozens is too low. I will bet you he goes top 10. Probably pushes Broberg down.
Not a huge Suzuki fan but he will go in the 1st
Afanasyev is too high and I am a fan.
I agree that Cozens goes top 10 and that Suzuki goes in the first. This is my opinion of them though, this isn’t projecting where they go. My mock draft will be added likely on draft day along with the scouting reports for the top 62. Might also add a few other things as well
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
Hugo Alnefelt? Big reason Sweden won U18 gold.
I don’t rank goalies. I said it earlier but from what I’ve seen, Knight is my number 1 and Trent Miner might be my number 2. There’s a few other guys I like as well like Portillo and Konovalov but I don’t watch goalies as much to rank them all properly. I also don’t think you can rank goalies among skaters
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hockeyfrilla

shylock104

Registered User
Mar 14, 2019
52
35
Great work, much appreciated my man. Based on this list (and the differing opinions that have come from them) it's looking like one of the best and deepest draft classes in awhile
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
Great work, much appreciated my man. Based on this list (and the differing opinions that have come from them) it's looking like one of the best and deepest draft classes in awhile
Thanks! It’s an average draft in my opinion, next year is the year to look out for though. 2020 is stacked
 
  • Like
Reactions: d rake

Vegan Knight

Registered User
Feb 16, 2018
5,178
2,728
I’m not a fan of Spence’s game. I think he has a low IQ and he has the tendency to make very dumb mistakes. In every viewing I had of Spence I came away with a bad impression, I’ve seen 5 games of Spence and 3 of Siedem’s. Spence reminds me a lot of Neal Pionk, even if he makes the NHL, I don’t want him on my team. Siedem is defensively sound and was 3rd in scoring for draft eligible dmen in the USHL, while playing on a meh team that doesn’t score much. He has a great frame to build into and he’s already defensively responsible. I think Siedem’s offensive upside is untapped and that developing at Harvard will only boost his stock

Out of every draft eligible I think Tomasino has developed the most this season. I think he was in my 80s earlier on and just forced his way up

I talked about Cozens a few posts above but Dach has higher offensive upside. Cozens screams Puljujarvi 2.0 with his tunnel vision, lack of a East/West game, and an inability to be effective in small spaces. For Cozens to create offense I’ve noticed he needs space. He’s not a quick thinker like Dach. I also think that while Cozens’ shot is very good in junior, it’ll have trouble in the NHL due to Cozens not being able to get it off fast enough. He skates around easily in junior and while it sounds like I’m hating on him, he doesn’t do much with the puck and I’ve noticed how bad his passing is. I’ve seen a lot of pucks die on his stick when they shouldn’t have as well. Dach also improved his skating and shot by a lot this season where as I haven’t noticed improvements in Cozens game

Broberg’s has one of the highest upsides in the class due to his skating, size, and shot. He’s pretty good defensively as well

I'm not saying that I think Broberg is overrated personally. I just meant I've seen write ups and other commenters list him as a prospect with higher bust potential but I don't know enough to have an opinion about him.

I do think maybe Seider is the one I'm hoping is there for Vegas to draft with our pick rather than Soderstrom or Broberg.
 

North Country

Registered User
Oct 24, 2012
494
95
Very good list even through the later rounds. The one prospect that catches my eye is Beecher being so low.
 

Lays

Registered User
Jan 22, 2017
13,559
12,630
Update-I have updated my list with my thoughts on my top 75. I shuffled a handful of guys around since I posted this list, most notably Misyul jumping to 21 and Lassi Thomson jumping to 25. Both were early 2nds for me but as I was writing my thoughts about each I thought both were 1st round caliber.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad