The problem is that he hasn't looked all that great just "running and gunning" either. 19 shots in 11 games isn't much gunning and his running has been akin to a football running back with poor vision that runs into his own linemen.
The size and speed is there but the critique's of his game (IQ, doesn't use his size, lack of good cycle game) have been on display. That said, it has been a few WJC games and 11 games plus pre-season of AHL since he's been drafted so it isn't expected that he would fix all of this by now. The lack of shots and dangerous chances is definitely a disappointment so far no matter how you slice it.
I was one of the biggest critics of Byfield from the WJCs and I disagree with most of this. After the tournament my expectation of him in the AHL were low, but almost every game he shows instances of why he was so highly touted.
To me he is the best Reign forward at the moment though an argument could be made for Kupari. Of course he makes mistakes and plays like an 18 year old at times. But given the fact in any other year he wouldn't even be there says a lot in terms of what he's done so far. He's like a train when he carries the puck in to the offensive zone. Speed, power and agility. More often than not he's able to gain entry and most of the time is the guy guy tasked with zone entry on the PP. He makes effective short passes which help with moving the puck up ice and his play making overall is above average. He's slowly starting to use his size more, and a great example was in the last game vs the Gulls when he beat 2 guys and made that back pass to whoever it was that created the outnumbered attack down low which in turn led to a goal.
I also disagree on his cycle game. Compared to the WJCs, his cycle game is night and day. In the WJC it seemed like every board play or cycle pass either went to the opposing player or no one at all. He was horrible in the tournament and it was so blatantly clear I think I even brought it up in one of my posts at the time. In the AHL, he's been much, much better; 10x better.
The only thing I'd agree with is that he definitely should shoot more.
I like what I'm seeing from Byfield and I understand the fact that he's far from polished. He was deemed more of a project / long-term development player and he's holding his own and doing well in a league he's not meant to be in on a shit ass team. 'Disappointment' is the last word I'd used to describe Byfield right now. And if that is how you feel about Byfield, I can't imagine what you think about Turcotte, Kaliyev, Madden, Thomas and Fagemo because in my opinion, he's played better than all of them.