Three true outcome baseball is the current flavor but I have to imagine there will be a team soon that becomes successful by getting a bunch of guys that you can't put the shift on. And then that will become the trend. These things are cyclical IMO.
True. It's a never ending battle of strategy adjustments. We're seeing that in NHL now too with the whole "play fast" thing, after everyone was all "CHI/LAK puck possession" craze.
I guess part of it is me getting old and falling victim to 'member berries ... but this is part of the reason I do not like the whole corsi adoption by a lot of people around hockey (i know you and I have had arguments on the whole corsi thing in the past). Part of it is because I don't want happened to baseball, happen to hockey.
I haven't watched baseball very much since about ~ 2005, even though I grew up watching baseball, and it was the first sport I loved/followed as a kid. (I still load up Tony LaRussa baseball 2 on Dosbox every 6 months or so, that should tell you where the source of my baseball fandom lies, so I'm not like any sort of "anti-stats" or "anit-sabermetrics" guy)
The only reason I started watching baseball again this year was because of the excitement around Shohei. After watching most of the NLCS and ALCS, and all of the world series - I just hate the current trend in baseball. They've somehow made a sport that is a little "slow" to watch to begin with, and made it even more dreadful. Watching Roberts throw away a world series win away in a pivotal part of the game simply because THE SPREADSHEET said it was the right move is just mind boggling to me.
I'm not a big Sciocia fan (i mean, how much of a dick do you have to be to not dress a guy on his bobble head night), but you gotta give the guy credit as a guy who at least "used to" be great at following hunches and going with his ever expanding gut in key moments. You look back at that 2002 run, and I don't think that happens in today's baseball. Guys like Eckstein and Kennedy, and Spiezio probably wouldn't sniff a MLB roster in today's game.