- May 17, 2011
- 60,380
- 9,685
Speculation: Kucherov to NYI
- Thread starter Butchered
- Start date
SI90
Registered User
The best post I've seen. I can't stand some of these proposals. From both sides to be clear.
- May 17, 2011
- 60,380
- 9,685
SI90
Registered User
To be quite honest, I think Kucherov has more value than Stamkos and is likely on par with Tavares (but Tavares is a beast of a first line center, on a beast of a contract- hence he's more valuable)
Nikita, after his insane clutch performances the past two postseasons has really opened my eyes as to what kind of scary "sixth sense" he has with accuracy and velocity on his shot. This guy is the Eastern conference Vlad Tarasenko, an UNTOUCHABLE piece up there with the likes of Sid,Ovechkin,Benn, Kane, Malkin, Karlsson, Tarasenko.
To add to that, a team like Tampa is VERY smart and ahead of the curve in the league, best drafting team post DRW dominance (So long Datsyuk-will miss you) so they would fleece the Islanders in ANY trade involving the two teams I'm sorry to say. Tampa just becomes scarier with each passing season.
Nikita, after his insane clutch performances the past two postseasons has really opened my eyes as to what kind of scary "sixth sense" he has with accuracy and velocity on his shot. This guy is the Eastern conference Vlad Tarasenko, an UNTOUCHABLE piece up there with the likes of Sid,Ovechkin,Benn, Kane, Malkin, Karlsson, Tarasenko.
To add to that, a team like Tampa is VERY smart and ahead of the curve in the league, best drafting team post DRW dominance (So long Datsyuk-will miss you) so they would fleece the Islanders in ANY trade involving the two teams I'm sorry to say. Tampa just becomes scarier with each passing season.
The time to trade for Tampa's youngins is gonna be when they're between a rock and a hard place during contract negotiations when they ultimately will have to shed cap due to their success. This is not the right offseason to alter the Islander's philosophy and trade away half their prospect cupboard for a sure fire elite first liner.
Sheva7
Work Hahd Play Smaht
- Oct 11, 2011
- 3,422
- 452
Yeah, I can't imagine us moving him and if we lose him because Yzerman resigned Stamkos to that ridiculous contract when Stammer wasn't living up to the one he had then Stevie Y. should be run out of town.
CupsOverCash
Registered User
- Jun 16, 2009
- 16,366
- 7,098
Kuch is the last guy who the Lightning should trade. I wouldn't trade him for anybody outside of Macdavid.
SI90
Registered User
A #2 top pairing defenseman a blue chip wing prospect and a 1st is ridiculous.
Defenseman are way too valuable in this league. Kucherov would be amazing but we make our team worse if we lost Hamonic.
Sheva7
Work Hahd Play Smaht
- Oct 11, 2011
- 3,422
- 452
Hamonic a #2? I think that's arguable. Imo he's replaceable.
Dal Colle blue chip? Maybe, maybe not...lots of ppl skeptical about him though, with good reason.
I'll agree that adding the 1st is probably overkill....but one thing is certain.....
Kucherov is amazing. End of story.
Dal Colle blue chip? Maybe, maybe not...lots of ppl skeptical about him though, with good reason.
I'll agree that adding the 1st is probably overkill....but one thing is certain.....
Kucherov is amazing. End of story.
SI90
Registered User
Kucherov is awesome. He's just now coming into his own and he's still young. But you can't afford to lose Hamonic.
Sheva7
Work Hahd Play Smaht
- Oct 11, 2011
- 3,422
- 452
Number1RedWingsFan52
Registered User
Hamonic only asked for a trade for family reasons to be close to home near Winnipeg, Or Western Canada and has since rescinded the deal. Snow isn't moving Hamonic now and doubt it's to Tampa.
Hictor Vedman*
Unregistered Hedman
Funny thing is I wouldn't do it.
The value is there, I have no problem with that whatsoever. The problem I have is Kucherov being moved, period. Thankfully, this forum's obsession with playing GM won't have any correlation with the real world.
Kucherov will be resigned, and then people will have to move on with their lives and play GM with some other player.
Sheva7
Work Hahd Play Smaht
- Oct 11, 2011
- 3,422
- 452
The trade request fiasco is over. He doesn't have an NTC. On top of that, expansion is coming...so we're going to lose a very good player anyway.
So all that considered, assuming the right deal comes around Snow would be totally justified if he were to ship out Hamonic.
Last edited:
PWJunior
Stay safe!
You obviously didn't get the memo that all Isles assets are garbage value and everyone else's are gold.
JT Kreider
FIRE GORDIE CLARK
Said the fan of every team that gets shut down for making offers for another teams best players for lesser pieces.
Number1RedWingsFan52
Registered User
Wouldn't mind seeing Hamonic in Tampa, But not for Kucherov that kid is some kind of special enjoyed watching him these past 2 seasons And looking for even better things out of him.
LeapOnOver
Mackenzie is a hack!
I'd absolutely do this too...in a world where Kutcherov was actually available I think this is fair value, maybe a slight overpayment by NYI but you would expect that in an in conference trade.
Unfortunately I don't think he's even close to being available, but yeah, I would do this in a heartbeat and not look back.
Could see him returning Hamonic, based on the Hall trade. I see the 2 having pretty similar value.
Which is precisely why it isn't fair value. That offer is like me saying I would trade Stralman + Point + 1st for Tavares: I'd do that in a heartbeat too but I very much doubt you would consider that fair value either.
