in a world where Kopitar won't be a Prime player for that long,
32 year old Malkin is still a top 3 center in the NHL.
33 year old Bergeron is still the best two-way player in hockey
33 year old Getzlaf is still an elite 1C
There is absolutely no reason that Anze Kopitar could not remain a top 20 NHL center.
everytime we play true contenders we get outplayed
That's just flat out wrong. In 2/3 meetings against the Leafs we outworked them, outchanced them and arguably outplayed them --- we lost in 3on3 OT. We have had a pretty solid record against playoff teams, and in our first game against Tampa this season we outplayed them, outchanced them and outworked them. This team lacks consistency, finish, and top end talent. Kopitar addresses all three areas.
We're the third youngest team in terms of average age, with Weber at 33 and Price at 31 being our oldest players. Some teams have better young stars (Toronto) but we're not going to suck enough to draft top 5 several times to get those players.
adding Kopitar doesn't fix our defense and you trade our best LHD prospect
As I said previously, Romanov is several years out from being NHL ready. He is not the solution to our defensive woes. And yes, adding a two-way center GENERALLY improves your defensive play.
you trade assets that could be use to get a younger player that fills a more important role
I'd argue outside of Goaltender there is no more important role than your #1 center. A role this team has gone too long without; hence our continual struggles.
you do not trade Poehling without seeing how his game translate.
He's not even looking at the NHL until he graduates college in 2020. He could also choose to walk thanks to the NCAA rule.
Carey price could stay a prime player for a very long time, Weber could be there as a top4 role
Price, Kopitar and Weber all have equal chance to stay relevant for equal time. Weber will have to adjust his game to play like Zdeno Chara, and Kopitar will eventually shelter himself as a #2 shutdown guy more than a #1 do-it-all, but likely they all remain fine well into their late 30s.
most of our roster is filled is young, you build around that you do not handicap your future simply because 2 of your good players are in their 30's.
Kotkaniemi is 18
Lehkonen is 23
Domi is 23
Drouin is 23
Mete is 20
Juulsen is 21
Brook is 19
Fleury is 20
Suzuki is 19
Ikonen is 19
Evans is 22
We would still have three second round picks in the next two drafts on top of the aforementioned prospects. We have no issues moving Poehling and Romanov as well as two first round picks because our team is young, we have young players performing and new kids getting eady to come up. Poehling becomes expendable, ESPECIALLY if we're getting Kotkaniemi, because of our center depth. Romanov is expendable because he is still several years out as I noted earlier. This team has the chance to compete within the next 3-5 years, and after that is when they should look to retool and get younger.