The Athletic - Boston Ken Dryden: Bettman and NHL concussions — Knee deep in the big muddy

Fenway

HF Bookie and Bruins Historian
Sponsor
Sep 26, 2007
68,904
99,358
Cambridge, MA
Those with access to The Atlantic this is a powerful essay by Ken Dryden.

Bettman is first and foremost a lawyer and he knows the legal swamp the NHL is facing with concussions. Dryden is also a lawyer who just happens to be in the Hockey Hall of Fame.

Dryden: Bettman and NHL concussions — Knee deep in the big...

Gary Bettman chooses not to talk publicly about concussions and the NHL, citing the pending litigation involving the former players. But to introduce the changes needed to make the NHL game safer has nothing to do with the lawsuit. Bettman can instruct the Competition Committee to begin exploring options tomorrow.

Bettman prizes loyalty in those who have stood by him — Jacobs, Anschutz and other owners; his main hockey lieutenant, Colin Campbell; and his other hockey guys. Bettman is an employee of the league, but after 25 years as its commissioner, he has earned the owners’ trust. He, not they, is the most powerful voice in hockey. He will not throw them under the bus. Yet his words put them into positions where, under oath, their answers bring embarrassment to themselves.

This is all so unnecessary. There is an easy, viable solution. Elbows and sticks to the head have been penalized for decades, and a stick to the face has brought an automatic penalty for the past several years. Penalize all hits to the head the same way — no excuses. No convoluted explanations. Whether such a hit is intentional or accidental, a “hockey play” or not, the brain doesn’t distinguish. It doesn’t care. The damage is the same.

NHL owners love Bettman. He has brought stability to their league, he has made the teams they own worth vastly more money, and he has brought competitive parity so that when things go wrong, their teams need not remain at the bottom for long. Almost universally, these owners have said nothing publicly about concussions and brain injuries. But these video depositions surely must make them squirm.
 

missingchicklet

Registered User
Jan 24, 2010
36,589
34,463
Those with access to The Atlantic this is a powerful essay by Ken Dryden.

Bettman is first and foremost a lawyer and he knows the legal swamp the NHL is facing with concussions. Dryden is also a lawyer who just happens to be in the Hockey Hall of Fame.

Dryden: Bettman and NHL concussions — Knee deep in the big...

Gary Bettman chooses not to talk publicly about concussions and the NHL, citing the pending litigation involving the former players. But to introduce the changes needed to make the NHL game safer has nothing to do with the lawsuit. Bettman can instruct the Competition Committee to begin exploring options tomorrow.

Bettman prizes loyalty in those who have stood by him — Jacobs, Anschutz and other owners; his main hockey lieutenant, Colin Campbell; and his other hockey guys. Bettman is an employee of the league, but after 25 years as its commissioner, he has earned the owners’ trust. He, not they, is the most powerful voice in hockey. He will not throw them under the bus. Yet his words put them into positions where, under oath, their answers bring embarrassment to themselves.

This is all so unnecessary. There is an easy, viable solution. Elbows and sticks to the head have been penalized for decades, and a stick to the face has brought an automatic penalty for the past several years. Penalize all hits to the head the same way — no excuses. No convoluted explanations. Whether such a hit is intentional or accidental, a “hockey play” or not, the brain doesn’t distinguish. It doesn’t care. The damage is the same.

NHL owners love Bettman. He has brought stability to their league, he has made the teams they own worth vastly more money, and he has brought competitive parity so that when things go wrong, their teams need not remain at the bottom for long. Almost universally, these owners have said nothing publicly about concussions and brain injuries. But these video depositions surely must make them squirm.

Been saying the bolded for a while now. I don't always agree with Dryden, but I certainly agree with him on this issue. I don't want big hits to go away. Heck, I don't even want fighting to go away. The NHL needs to take bigger steps in protecting its players while still providing fans with a fast physical sport. As I've said numerous times -- the players will adjust to the new rules as long as they are enforced consistently and without bias. The vast majority of big hits put the head in no danger. It's that small percentage of borderline hits that players need to take out of their game. Those borderline hits will decrease substantially if players learn that it's not worth the risk.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chief Nine

easton117

Registered User
Nov 11, 2017
5,078
5,659
Unless the league is going to mandate every player be the same height you will never get hits that connect with the head out of the game.

It sucks that guys get hurt. But there is absolutely nothing wrong with hits like the one Backes took vs Tampa where an incidental helmet to helmet collision took place on a clean body check. It’s a farce even recommending that you can police that.

The league needs to grow some stones and man up on two fronts: 1. They screwed the pooch up until about 10 years ago with regards to concussions. Eat your lawsuit just like the nfl did. 2. Every player in that league should be signing some kind of waiver recognizing they’re probably going to get dinged in the coconut at some point. It’s an unsafe work environment. That said the spotters or whatever they’re called should be held to a higher standard than they are now. Because those guys are a sick joke.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad