Critical13
Fear is the mind-killer.
Who would you take if you could draft 1 of 3 guys today, after 4 years of development?
I'm going to come off like a homer but Kapanen, Ho-Sang, Scherbak in that order.
If Ho-Sang wasn't such a headcase, it would be him by a country mile. He's done himself no favours from back when he was a high schooler.
One of those 'could have been' prospects. He still has time and hopefully he uses it.
To be honest, that play-style is sort of reflective of his personality issues. He tuned out coaches for years who wanted him to be quicker moving the puck, and not try to hold on forever looking for the highlight deke or pass. Maybe its a hockey-Iq issue, but it seems more like from at least the start of his time in Windsor he's been told not to do this and play a more team-oriented game and hasn't listened.I don't even think the bolded would be the case. I don't think Ho-Sang's style of play translates well to professional hockey, where no matter how much skill you have, you can't dangle through 5 opposition players every time you want.
Yet Ho-sang has produced quite a bit more in the NHL than the other two...I don't even think the bolded would be the case. I don't think Ho-Sang's style of play translates well to professional hockey, where no matter how much skill you have, you can't dangle through 5 opposition players every time you want.
GP | G | A | Pts | |
Ho-sang | 43 | 6 | 16 | 22 |
Kapanen | 55 | 8 | 2 | 10 |
Scherbak | 29 | 5 | 2 | 7 |
Yet Ho-sang has produced quite a bit more in the NHL than the other two...
[TBODY] [/TBODY]
GP G A Pts Ho-sang 43 6 16 22 Kapanen 55 8 2 10 Scherbak 29 5 2 7
You said you don't think Ho-sang's style of play translates well to professional hockey. All I did was point out that, in an admittedly small sample size, offensively Ho-sang's style of play seems to be translating much better than the other poll options.And? None of those totals are impressive. Yet Kapanen adds more to the table when he's not scoring. Ho-Sang literally needs to be a point per game forward or he's just a liability out there more often than not.
what about scherbak? whats your analysis about him?Ho Sang pretty easily. Kapanen can't seem to generate any offence at the NHL level.
You said you don't think Ho-sang's style of play translates well to professional hockey. All I did was point out that, in an admittedly small sample size, offensively Ho-sang's style of play seems to be translating much better than the other poll options.
I think you're being more than a little hyperbolic when you say Ho-sang would have to score PPG in order to not be a liability. Regardless, I would take his ceiling over Kapanen's floor.
Yet Ho-sang has produced quite a bit more in the NHL than the other two...
[TBODY] [/TBODY]
GP G A Pts Ho-sang 43 6 16 22 Kapanen 55 8 2 10 Scherbak 29 5 2 7
For me Kapanen>JHS>Scherbak but all 3 are close
Kapanen, I think he has a very likely chance of at least being a Grabner or Hagelin type player, with potential for more. His speed is utterly disruptive. The big thing for him will be does the game ever slow down mentally for him. If he can't start thinking the game at the speed he can play it, he has first line upside. If he doesn't, he a middle-sixer who can cause havoc with his speed and kill penalties.
To be honest, that play-style is sort of reflective of his personality issues. He tuned out coaches for years who wanted him to be quicker moving the puck, and not try to hold on forever looking for the highlight deke or pass. Maybe its a hockey-Iq issue, but it seems more like from at least the start of his time in Windsor he's been told not to do this and play a more team-oriented game and hasn't listened.
He absolutely does in a complimentary role. Teams don't always put their 3 best players on the first line. I just watched a team with a player with an even more limited skill set (Tom Wilson), win the cup being on the first line.I’m sorry, but Kapanen does not have first line upside. Not everyone in Toronto has to be the second coming lol
a top 6 role really helps doesnt it? kapanen hasnt played a second of PP time
Kapanen has 67 pts in his last 71 AHL games (2 seasons)
Ho sang has 67 in 100