Kane this season vs McDavid last season

[amnesiac]

Similar to the other thread vs Kuch... curious if people are just looking at points here.

Click to read more...

 

[daver]

From strictly a statistical perspective, Kane thru 60 games > McDavid thru 60 games last year based on their relative Art Ross placings and considering McDavid is about as good this year as he was thru 82 games last year.

 

[Nadal On Clay]

Kane.

 

[McDavidCrushedLarkin]

McDavid

 

[Cup or Bust]

Everyone is better then McDavid, and everything that is being done this season is better then anything McDavid has done before.

 

[ijuka]

McDavid because season scoring was lower. Kane isn't even leading.

 

[SotasicA]

McDavid because season scoring was lower. Kane isn't even leading.

Wasn't McDavid 2nd behind Kucherov last year this time as well?

 

[authentic]

Everyone is better then McDavid, and everything that is being done this season is better then anything McDavid has done before.

Well at this point in the season he is doing better statistically and relatively.

 

[Brucelenok]

Honestly, McDavid is becoming a bit overrated by a lot of people. His last season wasn't that whole special until like last 10-15 games, where he realized Edmonton out of play-off picture and took a lead from Kucherov. For me it is Kane.

 

[Dion TheFluff]

Kane
Not really that close either.
McDavid has become pretty overrated on here.

 

[Panthaz89]

Honestly, McDavid is becoming a bit overrated by a lot of people. His last season wasn't that whole special until like last 10-15 games, where he realized Edmonton out of play-off picture and took a lead from Kucherov. For me it is Kane.

I guess since none of the teams they played were getting ready for the playoffs they would just let the net be empty every time they saw McDavid on the ice and decided that they would rather risk losing their jobs by letting McDavid score on them.

 

[tony d]

Kane for me.

 

[Tad Mikowsky]

Lol at people saying McDavid is overrated.

 

[34]

Kane AINEC.

 

[GreatGonzo]

Honestly, McDavid is becoming a bit overrated by a lot of people. His last season wasn't that whole special until like last 10-15 games, where he realized Edmonton out of play-off picture and took a lead from Kucherov. For me it is Kane.

That’s actually false on every level. McDavid sat around the same pace the entire season with maybe a 3-4 point lead compared to the year prior. What your saying is just something you went along with because a large group of people who don’t like him decided that it was true, and you decided to follow it without even looking at the obvious stats that don’t back your claim. Also, McDavids ES Production alone put him in a different class.

 

[Sky04]

Kane because his torrid scoring pace isn't for nothing.

 

[Canovin]

Kane would have less points if he was coached by Hitch

 

[daver]

Kane would have less points if he was coached by Hitch

I see the McDavid PC police are hard at work. McDavid's PPG is higher since he was hired.

 

[Canovin]

I see the McDavid PC police are hard at work. McDavid's PPG is higher since he was hired.

Well of course, McDavid is only getting better each year.

 

[Sidney the Kidney]

Lol at people saying McDavid is overrated.

What's his P1/60 at 5on5 when playing on the road in tie games? Thought so!

 

[daver]

Well of course, McDavid is only getting better each year.

You mean better each month, right? PPG before Hitchcock -1.40, after hiring - 1.48.

 

[Tobias Kahun]

Honestly, McDavid is becoming a bit overrated by a lot of people. His last season wasn't that whole special until like last 10-15 games, where he realized Edmonton out of play-off picture and took a lead from Kucherov. For me it is Kane.

What are your thoughts on the year before when the oilers made the playoffs and McDavid increased his scoring near the end of the year aswell?

Or does that not fit the agenda you're trying to portray here.

 

[Bank Shot]

What are your thoughts on the year before when the oilers made the playoffs and McDavid increased his scoring near the end of the year aswell?

Or does that not fit the agenda you're trying to portray here.

It's propaganda started by Flames fans.

Pretty ridiculous.

 

[GlitchMarner]

Honestly, McDavid is becoming a bit overrated by a lot of people. His last season wasn't that whole special until like last 10-15 games, where he realized Edmonton out of play-off picture and took a lead from Kucherov. For me it is Kane.

If you're going to go by that standard, Kane's team was pretty much trash and at the bottom of the barrel when he started his point streak and his ascension up the ranks of the scoring race.

 

[GlitchMarner]

Kane because his torrid scoring pace isn't for nothing.

That's really only because of how horrible the race for the WC2 spot is. His scoring is impressive, but if he gets the Hart because his team finishes with like 85 points and sneaks into the playoffs, it'll be kind of ugh if Kucherov outscores him by a good margin.