Joe Micheletti
- Thread starter Jersey Girl
- Start date
Irishguy42
Mr. Preachy
Micheletti on national broadcasts is wayyyyyyy more tolerable than Micheletti on Rangers broadcasts.
He can stay there and never come back
YoSoyLalo
me reading HF
Dave Maloney is great but he wouldnt survive in TV with his all too honest commentary on the Radio...which is of course what I love about him.
Bob Richards
Mr. Mojo Risin'
Love that about him.
Dude gets absolutely heated about stuff and it feels so genuine and refreshing.
eco's bones
Registered User
I'm not a fan. Micheletti is something of a shill. He always toes the company line and as a color man I don't find him to be particularly insightful. Rosen would be better off without him--he makes Rosen worse than he should be IMO. Give Sam and us a better color guy. Maloney is fairly decent.
I do go back a ways and have to say I was not a fan of Jim Gordon or Bill Chadwick either. I always thought Marv Albert and Sal Messina on the Rangers radio broadcast were light years superior. Go back and look at some of the Rangers clips on youtube in the 70's and 80's and the commentary from Chadwick and Gordon is wincingly bad---puerile really. They weren't the only ones---the Flyers and Islanders TV people--just f***ing awful. There was almost always engaging commentary coming from the Rangers radio team though and I never could understand why the Rangers just didn't chuck those two f***heads and go with Albert and Messina instead. Marv also did the Knicks though and maybe that was partly why.
I do go back a ways and have to say I was not a fan of Jim Gordon or Bill Chadwick either. I always thought Marv Albert and Sal Messina on the Rangers radio broadcast were light years superior. Go back and look at some of the Rangers clips on youtube in the 70's and 80's and the commentary from Chadwick and Gordon is wincingly bad---puerile really. They weren't the only ones---the Flyers and Islanders TV people--just f***ing awful. There was almost always engaging commentary coming from the Rangers radio team though and I never could understand why the Rangers just didn't chuck those two f***heads and go with Albert and Messina instead. Marv also did the Knicks though and maybe that was partly why.
Gospel of Prospal
America's Team
What I always found hilarious was that Joe has such a great rapport with Sam. He'll goof around and make jokes. But when Joe is paired with John, it's STRICTLY business. No funny business.
I never thought he was particularly pro Rangers. When you compare him to the Jack Edwards types he doesn't even move the needle on the homer-meter. His analysis skills barely exist. Unless you want to know how tired the penalty killers are, Joe is next to useless. Nice guy and all, but the drop off from J.D. to Joe is like falling out of an airplane with no parachute.
SingnBluesOnBroadway
Retired
I think Joe does a great job both on MSG and on NBCSports.
JD was great his first couple of seasons before he turned into the King of the Shills.
There were certain Rangers he would not say a negative word about no matter what they did.
I knew he was done as a great TV guy when Messier made a drop pass to no one. An opposing player skated the length of the ice and scored. JD said nothing.
Edge
Kris King's Ghost
Jack Edwards isn't a commentator.
He's a 1980s pro wrestler.
Also a very unpleasant human being to be around.
To me at least, there's a difference between being a homer and being overtly critical and calling a guy out publicly for a mistake. When I think of homers, the bar is set at Cusick and Sanderson from WSBK in Boston. Blatant. J.D. was the best in the business for a good stretch. Bill Clement was good too. Some of the voices now leave me wondering. Like Milbury. He's the anti homer. He hates everyone and calls it that way. He's somehow turned being an average defenseman and far below average GM into a lifelong gig. I don't know how he's managed but he's got more lives than a cat.
Riche16
McCready guitar god
People are spoiled...
You want bad color commentary? Watch the Pens home games... listen to Phil Esposito call a Lightning game...
Do that for like:05 secs & Joe is a dream comparatively.
You want bad color commentary? Watch the Pens home games... listen to Phil Esposito call a Lightning game...
Do that for like:05 secs & Joe is a dream comparatively.
Age is catching up to Joe and he has the occaisonal blunder, but he still has decent knowledge and does decent color/booth analysis of plays.
Roo Returns
Skjeikspeare No More
We're incredibly lucky. Yes, Sam isn't as sharp as he once was and Joe can be to a hockey broadcast as cheesy as Dave Grohl has become to rock music (and I love both Joe and Dave Grohl lol) but after living in DC a few years and hearing Laughlin and Bennati do games, I will never take Rangers broadcasts for granted. The only other guys in the league I enjoyed as much were the old Sharks guys, but that team was split up a few years ago.
SingnBluesOnBroadway
Retired
- Sep 1, 2010
- 9,796
- 7,665
i don't mind Joe, I like Dave alot
most color guys don't add much,
i do really enjoy Ken Singleton and will miss him
who else can talk about switch hitters with such insight? just this weekend, he got the camera guys to compare Hicks' position in batters box right vs left
i also liked Jim Kaat
but most color guys, they don't say much worth paying attention to, often i mute the TV and play music, if i miss somethingthere are plenty of replays, and even 'rewind live TV'
the recent Yankee players - ONeill, Flaherty, Leiter, Cone, all sound almost the same to me, although Paulie never says anything you wouldn't come up with yourself, and the ex-pitchers do sometimes add good pitching insight
most color guys don't add much,
i do really enjoy Ken Singleton and will miss him
who else can talk about switch hitters with such insight? just this weekend, he got the camera guys to compare Hicks' position in batters box right vs left
i also liked Jim Kaat
but most color guys, they don't say much worth paying attention to, often i mute the TV and play music, if i miss somethingthere are plenty of replays, and even 'rewind live TV'
the recent Yankee players - ONeill, Flaherty, Leiter, Cone, all sound almost the same to me, although Paulie never says anything you wouldn't come up with yourself, and the ex-pitchers do sometimes add good pitching insight
eco's bones
Registered User
As far as color guys--I like Ken Daneyko--insightful, no bullshit--doesn't go off on tangents and if someone else does he brings it right back to subject. OTOH the Devils play by play guy might be the worst in the league and their new addition Bryce Salvador is awful. Butch Goring is hit and miss--he's better than Micheletti though. Rob Ray is good and I hate Rick Jeanrette. I don't like the Pittsburgh announcers or Boston's or the Capitals, Edwards makes Brickley a lot worse in Boston. Potvin sucks. Maloney, Valiquette or Carter would be better than Micheletti. Just saying---one guy I do miss is Bob Page. That guy was a trip.
mrmovies779
The Greatest Teacher,Failure is.
- Feb 5, 2013
- 7,052
- 6,521
Roo Returns
Skjeikspeare No More
I used to always tune into the 5 minute MSG Sportsdesk at 7 PM as a kid. Even begged my mom to make it home from errands multiple times, especially during the summer of 1991 when Richter was holding out, I was so worried the Flyers were going to offer sheet him LOL. He was un-PC, rude, and sarcastic, loved every minute of it. My favorite moment I've talked about several times on this board was when the Rangers traded Wells to get Lidster back in the summer of 1996 and he started the segment out with "Talk about trading Tweedle Dee for Tweedle Dumb" He even grew a mustache for a short period and looked like a total heel.
He ticked off Dolan with his attitude and opinions and was booted in the late 90s around the time the "Everything is always happy and sunshine in the wonderful world of MSG" PR mantra started.
He retired to Florida and still spends time in Michigan here and there. I had a chance to contact him through someone I knew around 2011 but didn't want to bother him. He's a Michigan guy at heart. He had some very negative things to say about NY Sports after he was dismissed.
