So Ryan Spooner wasn't constantly criticized for his lack of defensive prowess during his many years here? Ryan Donato isn't facing it right now?
Spooner just never improved defensively...at all and didn't seem to show any interest in it. I don't see Donato facing criticism for his defensive play. Does it come up? sure, but I think it depends on who he plays with. He's in his first full NHL, people don't expect him to be a polished defensive player. Despite his developing defensive game, people still had him in their lines-ups (until this love for Cehlarik started because of a few pre-season games) all off-season because of his offensive upside.
And depth scoring was ABSOLUTELY a problem last season. And it's part of the reason Kuraly on the third is so highly contested here. Why Acciari is argued to be a 13th forward and why many are confused as to why he seems to always make the top twelve.
When people talked of depth scoring, I don't recall people pointing fingers at the 4th line? If anything is was the 2nd/3rd line that took most of the heat..
20 points is not an unreasonable expectation for a forward who plays 3/4 or more of the season. That would be a guy who contributes on the scoreboard every once in a while.
I didn't say it was unreasonable, but looking at Nordstrom's career he's probably not going to be that guy. Again if you're expecting 20+ points from him, you'll probably be disappointed. Now whether that means he should or should be an everyday player, that's a different story.
It's certainly no more unreasonable than expecting a young scorer to show effort and competency in the defensive zone.
I'd agree which is why Pasta vs Spooner are so different. You see the willingness and improvement defensively for Pasta year over year...you never saw that with Spooner.
If we are to pump the brakes on 20 points for Nordstrom, he shouldn't be an everyday player.
Maybe he shouldn't be. Right now though it doesn't appear there is anyone in the system that is taking his job from him.