I won't start to argue about your last line as I hate arguments that can't be proven with stats or something on paper. But I still stand behind my words, at the start of their NHL careers Yamamoto and Pulju had different treatments. It's been seen as such a clear fact here I shouldn't even have to talk about that. Anyway, I'm truly happy about Yamamoto's great season.
https://thehockeywriters.com/oilers-puljujarvi-yamamoto-ahl/
In my mind, Puljujarvi should have been given more of an opportunity to earn his place but at the end of the day, that isn’t how the coaching staff and/or organization see it and that is all that matters.
Yamamoto isn’t in quite the same situation, as the former Spokane Chiefs standout has been given an extended look inside the top six and hasn’t looked completely out of place. However, two points in eleven games, most of which has come skating alongside McDavid, isn’t enough production.
Yamamoto vs Puljujarvi
Yamamoto has been locked into Edmonton’s top 6 from day one and climbed his way to McDavid’s wing. Puljujarvi started on the third and pushed higher briefly before finding himself a healthy scratch for what will now be four straight games.
The cold hard fact is that through 10 games, Yamamoto has fewer points than he did after 9 games a season ago.
Yamamoto has one 5v5 point, a goal, and one assist on the power play. He’s been playing more than 14 minutes a night in Edmonton’s top 6 and a staple on the 2nd PP unit, but he has just 11 shots on net in 10 games. While paired with Connor McDavid on the top line, the Oilers are scoring less than 1 goal per hour 5v5, and he’s played over an hour 5v5 with McDavid. In fact, he’s played with McDavid more than any other RW this season.
Jesse Puljujarvi is just 145 days older than Kailer Yamamoto but while one is being given all the opportunity in the world despite his production, the other seems on the verge of washing out of the team.
They are so close in age and yet have been handled completely differently from each other, which is also playing into how we perceive them.
What doesn’t hold up to any scrutiny is telling me that these two players are extremely different in their effectiveness and that one has earned top line minutes while the other has earned four straight games in the press box.
And more in the discussion section...