From God's lips to GloveSave's ear...to Chia's ear?
So, you admit you are basing your assumptions on last year's data, and you still haven't addressed the wild idea that players can actually...Gasp!...improve.
If Bartkowski hasn't improved and is the same guy from the playoffs last year, then he absolutely should not be given a shot at the Top 4. FWIW, I thought he looked pretty damned good tonight playing the majority of the game with Sides on his right. The two of them were matched up with Tavares-Okposo and Nelson all night and Bart did a really nice job on JT in a couple of one one one situations.
A couple of his stretch passes were off the mark and resulted in icing calls, and he got caught flat-footed on one play where a B had a bad turnover just outside the B's blue line (think it was Florek?). Other than that, his decision making was sound, his passes were good, and his play got noticeably chippy as the play got more intense in the 3rd.
If they were "showcasing" him, his value just went up.