Confirmed with Link: Jason Botterill Hired As General Manager -- MOD WARNING #1851

Status
Not open for further replies.

SnuggaRUDE

Registered User
Apr 5, 2013
8,924
6,466
Housley sucks, yes. But that doesn't mean that his drop off in play has anything to do with the coach killing his confidence. I'm surprised how often this is thrown around in hockey considering professional athletes as a whole are a very confident bunch.

The human mind has a really difficult time with variance.
 

Chainshot

Give 'em Enough Rope
Sponsor
Feb 28, 2002
147,572
96,012
Tarnation
I think a 3C would be enough if they played in the western conference. But in the east they need a 2C to make the playoffs.

Having been an advocate that Botterill make a bolder move early in the season, before pre-deadline price inflation set in by targeting Hayes when the Rangers were experiencing pressure in the standings to begin a retool. He slots in right now as a 2C and can then be displaced down to a 3C. The bold part is both making the move and having the moxy to get him signed to an extension. It wouldn't surprise me in the least if Hayes signs with whoever rents him out at the deadline -- which likely won't be Buffalo.
 

Chainshot

Give 'em Enough Rope
Sponsor
Feb 28, 2002
147,572
96,012
Tarnation
Housley sucks, yes. But that doesn't mean that his drop off in play has anything to do with the coach killing his confidence. I'm surprised how often this is thrown around in hockey considering professional athletes as a whole are a very confident bunch.

The human mind has a really difficult time with variance.

And yet it gets brought up by those who both participate in the game and commentate on it at a high (ie. professional) level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sabremike

DatGuy

Registered User
Sep 25, 2015
1,151
353
I think they are OK with these lines

Skinner-Eichel-ERod
Sheary-Mitts-Reinhart
Smith-[Upgrade]-Thompson
Girgs-Larry-[Warm body]
Agreed, but is this something we go for in the off season? Is it to late for this year?
 

truthbluth

Registered User
Feb 2, 2011
7,155
6,376
The only move Botts could make that would rectify my opinion of him would be to acquire and sign Mark Stone. Anything short of that, and I’m just counting the days until he’s gone. The RoR trade will go down as the worst trade in team history.
 

pf8363

Registered User
Feb 17, 2015
109
38
Botterill's inaction on defense has been alarming. Going into the season the Sabres had 10 defensemen that were realistic options to play in the NHL. He even later added an 11th in Tennyson. That left them with:

Dahlin
Risto
Bogosian
Scandella
Beaulieu
McCabe
Hunwick
Nelson
Guhle
Pilut
Tennyson

While Guhle has been a disappointment this year, Pilut and Nelson have solidified themselves as NHL players. Even with sending Tennyson down via waivers, the Sabres still have played most of the season with 9 defensemen on the NHL roster. This has resulted in a stupid carrousel of players going in and out of the bottom pair in a futile attempt to keep everyone happy. Better players are being left in the press box because "it was the other guy's turn". Beaulieu requested a trade over a month ago. Botterill has had all season to make moves to clean up this mess and has done nothing. All he had to do was ship a guy like Beaulieu/McCabe/Scandella out for a mid-late round pick. Five months later and we're still here in this situation with zero action or plan
 
  • Like
Reactions: debaser66

Kyndig

Registered User
Jan 3, 2012
5,147
2,862
I think they are OK with these lines

Skinner-Eichel-ERod
Sheary-Mitts-Reinhart
Smith-[Upgrade]-Thompson
Girgs-Larry-[Warm body]

Skinner-Eichel-Olofsson
Sheary-Mitts-Reinhart
Smith-Erod-Thompson
Girgs-Larry-Beaulieu...yes Beaulieu! haha was trying to use someone on our roster but all I saw was trash. Hey hes got just as many goals as Suckbotka while playing 27 fewer games as a defenseman!

Honestly though your lines look good. We haven't really seen Erod with Eichel even though they dominate when they're together.
 

brian_griffin

"Eric Cartman?"
May 10, 2007
16,596
7,798
In the Panderverse
I think a 3C would be enough if they played in the western conference. But in the east they need a 2C to make the playoffs.
baby steps. They have a 1C, 4C, a young learning C who shouldn't be relied on yet to drive a line, and a boat anchor in Sobotka whom you pair with teammates who need to work on their D-zone game, because it's a guaranteed 45-75 second shift running around your own D-zone any time Vlad hops the boards.

I think they are OK with these lines

Skinner-Eichel-ERod
Sheary-Mitts-Reinhart
Smith-[Upgrade]-Thompson
Girgs-Larry-[Warm body]
Smith-Upgrade-Thompson will be caved in unless Upgrade is major upgrade.

Cogliano and Shore both could have fit the bill. Bjugstad could have been a change of scenery guy. Heck, even Brassard would have helped.

The standard here isn't a "perfect 2C fit", its a "can we find someone better than ****ing Sobotka please"...which we could have.
Doak gets it, as usual.

And, in particular, that trigger should have been pulled 2 months ago when Berglund's cap went away. Botts signs Reinhart to a bridge to save cap this/year next, yet doesn't act on anything.

If there was a time to take a cap dump, or lose a trade, it would / should have been for a (another, i.e., mid-season) depth center who could have bumped Sobotka to the wing / down in TOI, and similarly sheltered Mittelstadt. What's a million or two incremental cap spend to lose a trade in value to finally get the Sabres back to the playoffs (or at least have a decent shot at them)?

Rail away at Murray all you wish, but bringing in ROR to shelter Eichel was both the right tactical and strategic move. Eichel's grown and developed. Maybe an ROR-like talent isn't needed, but an upgrade on Berglund / Sobotka sure was / is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hasekperreault23

slip

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Aug 19, 2005
15,998
4,449
Having been an advocate that Botterill make a bolder move early in the season, before pre-deadline price inflation set in by targeting Hayes when the Rangers were experiencing pressure in the standings to begin a retool. He slots in right now as a 2C and can then be displaced down to a 3C. The bold part is both making the move and having the moxy to get him signed to an extension. It wouldn't surprise me in the least if Hayes signs with whoever rents him out at the deadline -- which likely won't be Buffalo.
Bott’s is going 100% in on Mittelstadt as a legit 2C, and I hate that bet. Seems risky and stupid, almost ego driven.
 

MrMaster

Registered User
Apr 20, 2016
815
305
Doak gets it, as usual.

And, in particular, that trigger should have been pulled 2 months ago when Berglund's cap went away. Botts signs Reinhart to a bridge to save cap this/year next, yet doesn't act on anything.

If there was a time to take a cap dump, or lose a trade, it would / should have been for a (another, i.e., mid-season) depth center who could have bumped Sobotka to the wing / down in TOI, and similarly sheltered Mittelstadt. What's a million or two incremental cap spend to lose a trade in value to finally get the Sabres back to the playoffs (or at least have a decent shot at them)?

Rail away at Murray all you wish, but bringing in ROR to shelter Eichel was both the right tactical and strategic move. Eichel's grown and developed. Maybe an ROR-like talent isn't needed, but an upgrade on Berglund / Sobotka sure was / is.

So basically you're saying that it is all politics? Sobotka is playing, Thompson too, because they were part of the ROR deal and Botts wants to justify this trade.
Additionally, Oloffson is not playing because either Thompson takes his spot, or he was part of a former regime.

If this is true, if there are politics involved here, then this would be f***ing disgusting. I hope it's not.
 

fingerpainter

Registered User
Dec 20, 2018
97
40
Bott’s is going 100% in on Mittelstadt as a legit 2C, and I hate that bet. Seems risky and stupid, almost ego driven.

He's using the assets the Sabres have acquired over time, and not making impulsive decisions. I respect that. After Berg and Sobots didn't pan out, they for sure need some secondary support, but I'm grateful JB isn't jumping the gun just yet.
 

brian_griffin

"Eric Cartman?"
May 10, 2007
16,596
7,798
In the Panderverse
So basically you're saying that it is all politics? Sobotka is playing, Thompson too, because they were part of the ROR deal and Botts wants to justify this trade.
Additionally, Oloffson is not playing because either Thompson takes his spot, or he was part of a former regime.

If this is true, if there are politics involved here, then this would be ****ing disgusting. I hope it's not.
I'm not saying it, although others have suggested it.

Botts / Housley look at Sobotka in the same vein some people watch Jenny Craig commercials and see Kirstie Alley in her Cheers / Star Trek II TWOK days.
 

sabremike

Friend To All Giraffes
Aug 30, 2010
22,440
33,627
Brewster, NY
He's using the assets the Sabres have acquired over time, and not making impulsive decisions. I respect that. After Berg and Sobots didn't pan out, they for sure need some secondary support, but I'm grateful JB isn't jumping the gun just yet.
Giving away our second best player last summer sure seems like an impulsive decision to me.
 

MrMaster

Registered User
Apr 20, 2016
815
305
I'm not saying it, although others have suggested it.

Botts / Housley look at Sobotka in the same vein some people watch Jenny Craig commercials and see Kirstie Alley in her Cheers / Star Trek II TWOK days.

It never crossed my mind. I read about it here, but ignored it.
It started to creep in, with Oloffson playing so well, and Thompson deserving a benching at least once. Also that Sobotka thing, i guess it's true, he really doesn't produce at all, and a cheap acquisition for a 3C was possible i guess.

Please, Botts, don't be an idiot, you would deserve losing your job if that is the case..
 

SnuggaRUDE

Registered User
Apr 5, 2013
8,924
6,466
If Botts was keeping Olofsson down for political reasons why bring up Smith? Thompson plays the right side Olofsson plays the left. Olofsson plays his off side during the power play. Not 5v5.
 

SnuggaRUDE

Registered User
Apr 5, 2013
8,924
6,466
baby steps. They have a 1C, 4C, a young learning C who shouldn't be relied on yet to drive a line, and a boat anchor in Sobotka whom you pair with teammates who need to work on their D-zone game, because it's a guaranteed 45-75 second shift running around your own D-zone any time Vlad hops the boards.

Smith-Upgrade-Thompson will be caved in unless Upgrade is major upgrade.

Doak gets it, as usual.

And, in particular, that trigger should have been pulled 2 months ago when Berglund's cap went away. Botts signs Reinhart to a bridge to save cap this/year next, yet doesn't act on anything.

If there was a time to take a cap dump, or lose a trade, it would / should have been for a (another, i.e., mid-season) depth center who could have bumped Sobotka to the wing / down in TOI, and similarly sheltered Mittelstadt. What's a million or two incremental cap spend to lose a trade in value to finally get the Sabres back to the playoffs (or at least have a decent shot at them)?

Rail away at Murray all you wish, but bringing in ROR to shelter Eichel was both the right tactical and strategic move. Eichel's grown and developed. Maybe an ROR-like talent isn't needed, but an upgrade on Berglund / Sobotka sure was / is.

Getting a 2C 35 games into the season is nearly impossible. How many teams want to openly tank like that so early? Dylan Strome was moved, but for an almost equally young 2C.
 

Sabreality

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Aug 12, 2008
10,581
4,264
Atlanta, GA
Getting a 2C 35 games into the season is nearly impossible. How many teams want to openly tank like that so early? Dylan Strome was moved, but for an almost equally young 2C.
Agreed, I would have loved for him to make a move when Berglund took off, but not sure what would've really been out there outside the likes of the Gagners/Spooners of the league. Even Rask returned a good player in Nino. Should he have looked towards an Anisimov/Wennberg type? But those contracts...
 

SnuggaRUDE

Registered User
Apr 5, 2013
8,924
6,466
Agreed, I would have loved for him to make a move when Berglund took off, but not sure what would've really been out there outside the likes of the Gagners/Spooners of the league. Even Rask returned a good player in Nino. Should he have looked towards an Anisimov/Wennberg type? But those contracts...

It would have been nice to get a midstream 2C, but I don't view it as plausible.
 

Chainshot

Give 'em Enough Rope
Sponsor
Feb 28, 2002
147,572
96,012
Tarnation
Bott’s is going 100% in on Mittelstadt as a legit 2C, and I hate that bet. Seems risky and stupid, almost ego driven.

It could be ego. I just think he thought Casey was further along the development curve than he actually is. And that scares me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->