What do you mean I sound like I'm talking about Johnson? He was blown up in 2 of his 3 starts? Well he did have a shutout (or was it a one goal against game?) in one, which is something Schneider hasn't done in quite a while.
In fact Schneider has allowed 3 goals in his last 16 consecutive starts in the regular season and hasn't won any of them. The last time he allowed fewer than 3 in the regular season was December 27th of 2017. He did allow 2 goals in all 3 of his starts against Tampa in the playoffs, but his save percentage is .908% over his last 107 or 108 NHL games played, going back to October 2016. That's even including his excellent playoff series. I think it's about .907% if you take away those 3.5 games. It might even be .906% going back to November of 2016 and his last 95 or so games played, as he had one of his best October's in his career in 2016, before falling off about a week or so before Thanksgiving.
I do think he's been a bit unlucky to not have a single win in those 16 regular season starts, as a lot of goalies can have a win while allowing 3 goals. So he probably should have won 2-3 of those games, so the wins are irrelevant to me. What isn't irrelevant is his 16 straight regular season starts of allowing at least 3 goals. That's troubling. I'm waiting for him to have a 2 goal against game just on complete accident, with 3 shots hitting the post and 2 very soft goals against, but that hasn't even happened for him in the regular season since then and he's lost his starting job due to not making enough saves.
In conclusion, I think you are worse off with his contract than Allen's, as I believe the Blues are a cap ceiling team, if not close to it. I'm hoping we buy out Schneider after this year. I think it needs to happen. I super strongly believe it needs to happen. If he's not forced into LTIRement.