Bus, you forgot Cam.
Advanced stats again and again show that our "heavies" (Anderson/Foligno/Jenner/Dubinsky) don't play well together. The eye test shows the same thing at how awful Jenner and Dubinsky are together.
I'm more open to your suggestion that Nash play more with the "skilled" guys than Dubinsky does. I rather have Nash anchoring our shutdown line (whichever one that ends up being) rather than Dubi, however. And playing Nash and Dubinsky on the same line, when those are far and away our best two faceoff men, is just silly.
I could see something like:
Panarin-PLD-Atkinson
Duclair/Milano-Wennberg-Bjorkstrand
Jenner-Nash-Foligno
Robinson/Sedlak/Duclair-Dubinsky-Anderson
Duclair/Milano/Sedlak as forward 13
Jesus that's bad. I was looking past the 1st line pretty much. Something didn't seem right on the wings, but I couldn't think why. But ya, Atkinson is right there with Dubois IMO as somebody who is downplayed by MANY CBJ fans. "Consistency" is somewhat of an issue, but like
other players that are given a pass, I could see Cam playing through many injuries that we never hear about.
Do these "advanced" stats tell us that the "heavies" don't "play well", or that they don't score a lot of points or get a lot of chances offensively? And, if these "advanced" stats tell us that they are supposedly allowing a lot of "chances" against ('per-60 min'="numbers" multiplied), what impact does the fact that they are most of the time probably PUT TOGETHER MATCHED UP AGAINST TEAMS BEST PLAYERS
affect such "advanced" numbers? Our "eyes" aren't watching the same things, and our "ears" aren't listening to the same people.
Really don't have a problem with your lines, but that 2nd line would have to be quite sheltered. The "2 way" abilities of lines 3 and 4 would make up for it though. I see no issue with Dubinsky and Nash being on the same line for really ANY reason. They would work together "perfect" on a legit "shutdown"/"responsible" line. Them being our best 2 faceoff guys shouldn't be looked at the same as in the past, with the new faceoff rules. And if we were really going with 1 STRONG defensive/shutdown/heavy/etc. line, it actually (imo)
would make sense to put them together. 1st guy would be not be afraid to take a risk. However, Foligno and Jenner are also good on draws, BUT with how the faceoffs are it makes sense to have 1 of them on a different line for the same reason you think Dubi and Nash together is "silly". And also, I really think that Sedlak deserves an opportunity at regular icetime (roughly 10 min) although I don't think it matters if at center or wing. I like Dubi and Sedlak together.