Speculation: Islanders need a defenceman?
- Thread starter caley
- Start date
Pelech was holding down the fort well, Mayfield is an unknown at this point to replace Seids. I doubt we see a trade for a D, probably more for a RW to get us ready for when the D come back. This year is not looking great though.
Sparksrus3
Registered User
- Jun 2, 2012
- 10,029
- 4,908
Shooting at the walls of heartache
Bang bang
I am _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .
Or
Nik grossmann come on down
Bang bang
I am _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .
Or
Nik grossmann come on down
Last edited:
Maybe Berube can play defense for us. I mean why not? He doesn't do anything but sit in the press box anyway.
KasperTheGrittyGhost
Registered User
The issue with Mayfield is he will need waivers (and will be claimed) so if he comes up he may get the Berube treatment most of the year as the 7D.
He was. He cleared and is now with Charlotte. The AHL team not the ... never mind.
Sparksrus3
Registered User
- Jun 2, 2012
- 10,029
- 4,908
Mcilrath just recently cleared waivers
I think we can agree he is better than our Mayfield.
chupanibre
The GhostBear Cometh
Isles need a dman, 4 or 5 forwards, a coach, a GM, a pp, a pk.....ohhhh, and an arena with decent ice!
Magua
Entirely Palatable Product
caley
Moderator
Mayfield cleared waivers just over a month ago on October 6th. His being claimed this time is far from a sure thing.
KingCanadain1976
Registered User
berube for greene Gravel is playing well making greene available and La gets a goalie to fill in till quick gets back Greene is playing well but gravel is playing better win win
LordNeverLose
Registered User
This is silly. No chance the Isles trade for a defenseman. They have 3 guys out fairly short-term (Hamonic is the most at a month) and have basically 8 or 9 NHL ready defensemen, with significant holes elsewhere on the roster that need to be addressed.
McFlyingV
Registered User
How untouchable is Hamonic? My guess is very considering Snow's loyalty to him, but I almost wonder if a Dougie Hamilton + a forward for Hamonic could work. I just can't think off the top of my head if Calgary has any forwards good enough that NYI would be interested in, but not too good as to throw the value of the deal way off.
Probably not something that they could make work, but my thought process is that NYI get a Dman thats healthy and can play now, who is a #3 with top pair upside, although if the NYI think Pulock is their future offensive guy they might not be that interested. Then from the Flames side they could really use a Dman like Hamonic, and with the way their season has started they can probably accept that he won't be playing for a month+ and look towards next season.
If anyone has any feedback or can think of a deal that could work on this premise, I'd be very interested.
Probably not something that they could make work, but my thought process is that NYI get a Dman thats healthy and can play now, who is a #3 with top pair upside, although if the NYI think Pulock is their future offensive guy they might not be that interested. Then from the Flames side they could really use a Dman like Hamonic, and with the way their season has started they can probably accept that he won't be playing for a month+ and look towards next season.
If anyone has any feedback or can think of a deal that could work on this premise, I'd be very interested.
PROMputt
I promise to never forget.
LordNeverLose
Registered User
Logic's not horrible and I'd honestly be open to Dougie+ for Hamonic, but I think the only way the Front Office even considers moving Hammer is for help up front.
McFlyingV
Registered User
Yeah its a tough one to balance out because Calgary can't really afford to give up a guy like Monahan, or Bennett or Tkachuk given how little quality top 6 players they already have. I was originally thinking maybe something like Hamonic+Strome+Barzal/Beauvillier/MDC (not saying those 3 players have the same value, just tossing some names out) for Hamilton + Bennett or Tkachuk. I just don't know if Calgary can afford to give up Bennett or Tkachuk at this point.
Also the value of that type of deal might need to be balanced a little more.
LordNeverLose
Registered User
Last thing NYI need is another LW, so I doubt they'd want Tkachuk no matter how good he's been. Maybe they could target Monahan or Bennett as a 2C, but I dunno if CGY would be interested inn that.
Hamonic + Strome + MDC
for
Hamilton + Monahan/Bennett + 2nd
just trying something
