Considering he's never even won a Norris, I think there's at least a debate to be had.
It's extremely difficult to win a Norris, and Weber probably could've won a couple and nobody would've questioned it, but the fact is he hasn't. I think he's a HoFer, but we're not talking about Lidstrom here.
I didn’t even realize he never won a Norris. I’m shocked, he’s been a stud defenseman for so long and has generally always been considered one of the top defenders for so many years. It kind of reminds me on how Luongo never won a Vezna.
Anyways, this ones a good debate. If you judge the hall of fame on hardware, he really shouldn’t be in consideration. But I think it should be more than that, he’s definitely get my vote.