Discussion in 'Polls - (hockey-related only)' started by olli, Mar 12, 2018.
100% for me
He is in that range. Exactly top 10 is hard to say, so many guys basically at the same level. I’ll vote yes.
You really have Letang and Keith over Klingberg and Ghost?
No. He needs to get better away from the puck.
Have Jones in top 10, but also agree, how is it possible? Letang and Keith hahahha.
I love Ghost but top 10? Come on. Also agree those 2 shouldn't be up there.
That's my top 5 actual all around deserve credit for all ends D.
Werenski (getting there. He missed like 10 games or so or he might be closer to 20 goals.)
Those are 5 of the best D that are ok at D but their offensive skill keeps their names in it. Klinberg is the best defender in there. Werenski is still green but has the potential to be in that top 5 in 5-10 years. Subban Burns and Ghost are basically 4th forwards.
Subban is an outstanding defensive d-man. He plays very hard minutes and excels. You're full of it.
Go search YouTube and search for Subban getting walked it's not rare. I don't know why I'm full of it for calling the guy a top 5 offensive Dman like that's offensive.
Subban might have some odd turnovers but he's a shutdown defender
Yes, what a stud, incredible range and he is only getting better.
He has some odd gaffes, but your opinion makes much more sense now that I know you use YouTube highlights to determine defensive ability.
What? I said look it up if you want to see examples of why I think he's a average D with elite offense. [mod]
[mod] Way to try to imitate my comment and fail at it.
Random clips aren't examples you can use to "prove" something that is so obviously untrue, which you'd see if you took the time to watch whole games.
You referred to Subban as a 4th forward. Shows what you know.
He's in a mess of players around 6-15, but I said yes.
He might even be top 5. One of the top 4 best "young D" in the league.
He's in the mix with Hedman, Karlsson and Dahlin.
Especially since every dman has clips out there of them getting danced around or caught in a bad defensive play. Happens to the best of them
Looks like Slavin passed the torch to Jones.
All around he’s great but lindholm is arguably the best defensive dman in the league
This thread is a mess. Despite a couple hot months, Jones is not a top 10 damn yet IMO. He’s in the 10-15 range until he sustains this level of play for longer.
Ghost and Klingberg in top 10? Josi over Pietrangelo? Dahlin in the convo? Jones top 5? Subban 4th forward? Letang laughed at when put in top 10? Wtf am I reading?
he didn't mean he was a forward. [mod] shows what you know
Says the Ducks fan. He's great, but certainly not the best
Dahlin hasn't even played a game yet lmao. Ridiculous comment. He's also not even in the league yet, are you for real? Not even guaranteed to succeed. I really hope this kid busts or doesn't live up to expectations so people like you will learn to not assume things
Separate names with a comma.