How would you rank the bluelines of all organisations?

[Ajacied]

Using HF's prospect criteria ofcourse.. Anyone willing to take a stab at a top 10/15 or even more? I'm just curious to where some teams rank, including the Stars.

Click to read more...

 

[Vlad The Impaler]

Do you mean blueliner prospects only? Or also pro? Or just pro?

Just throw the guidelines and you'll get responses that are in sync

 

[Ajacied]

Do you mean blueliner prospects only? Or also pro? Or just pro?

Just throw the guidelines and you'll get responses that are in sync

Well gee, genius.. since I said "using HF's prospect criteria ofcourse", make a wild guess.

Strictly using prospects, yup.

 

[Vlad The Impaler]

For blueliners, I love the Hawks, then the Preds.

Also really like Pens.

Then there's the Coyotes, Oilers, Caps, Bruins and Sharks.

Then another drop to teams like the Sharks, Thrashers, Flames and Stars.

Ok, my post is not really useful. But I did it from memory and don't feel like digging further. I expect some team fan of a team I forgot to jump in and say: "what about the X?" in 3-2-1...

 

[Le Golie]

What about the Leafs?

 

[Ajacied]

What about the Leafs?

Where would you place them?

 

[db23]

Well gee, genius.. since I said "using HF's prospect criteria ofcourse", make a wild guess.

Strictly using prospects, yup.

No need to prove you're a SNOT, Ott. Your post is very vague and the guy was just asking for clafication. The post is pointless enough as it is without having to endure insults.

 

[Ajacied]

No need to prove you're a SNOT, Ott. Your post is very vague and the guy was just asking for clafication. The post is pointless enough as it is without having to endure insults.

I was only kidding.. Not my fault you have a slow connection and didn't see the smilie up untill now.

 

[Paxon]

No need to prove you're a SNOT, Ott. Your post is very vague and the guy was just asking for clafication. The post is pointless enough as it is without having to endure insults.

Aside from the obvious camaraderie the two share, he actually did say "Using HF's prospect criteria ofcourse". But kudos for sticking up for someone, which is always a nice thing to do.

 

[Vlad The Impaler]

db23, thanks for the intention but it is true, O=S and I are on good terms and I knew he was kidding.

Anyway, no harm done to anybody so I vote for world peace!







Ok, I'll be realistic. Thread peace?

 

[degroat*]

St Louis. Oh wait, I thought you asked for the worst one.

 

[NewHabsEra*]

Nashville has an impressive bunch of defensemans...

Edit:No Weber in their top 15?

Stehlik over Weber?

 

[SmokeyClause]

Nashville has an impressive bunch of defensemans...

Edit:No Weber in their top 15?

Stehlik over Weber?

It hasn't been updated yet.

 

[X-SHARKIE]

Sharks defensman prospects are likely untouched in terms of depth.

 

[Bill McNeal]

I wish the Habs had depth on D with our prospects

Komisarek (who I think is great) just graduated, so doesn't count.
Hainsey is full of himself and may never make it (fingers crossed)
Korneev is solid and has good Captain skills, but he's more likely not to make the NHL than to make it.
Beauchemin... Got size, but ya never know.

Next draft, I'm hoping Habs either get a power forward or a solid d prospect (if it's the best player available, of course).

Though, overall it's not too bad. Arguably our two best defensemen are quite young (Markov and Souray.)

 

[infinitesadd]

Sharks defensman prospects are likely untouched in terms of depth.

Pens and Hawks both match them.

 

[X-SHARKIE]

Pens and Hawks both match them.

There are a handfull of teams that out due the Sharks top end prospect depth on the defensman....but I mean just shear number of guys who could at least make a 5th or 6th defensman role.

It's impressive.

 

[Evilo]

Lupaschuk, Bissonnette, Fata, Rouleau, Scuderi, Nemec, Goligoski, Sersen, Malenkhyk, Fernholm, Schneider, Peluso, Lannon, etc...
All these guys have at least 5th-6th upside. Then add Whitney and Welch.

 

[Zoo]

I hope the pens can bring over Malenkhyk next season. Orpik and Malenkhyk would become to of the best up and coming open ice hitters.

I must say the Hawks look pretty soild for years to come.

Barker
Babchuk
Seabrook
Barinka
Keith
Kukkonen

 

[Jason MacIsaac]

I love Chicago....I fel they are the best by a good margin over Pittsburgh who is 2nd on my list.

Edit: Nashville is 2nd on my list and very close to Chicago...I forgot about Weber, Klein and Suter...