This is a fun question because it made me recall a lot of fun (and sad) memories. I remember watching Shanahan and being a big fan of him. So, probably 94-95. I got *really* into hockey when I joined SIUCs roller hockey club which was in 98. I tried for the Blues board moderator board at hockeyboards.com, but KeyserSoze beat me to it, and I was assigned the Avalanche. To build a user base I watched every single Avs game and posted multiple times a day on the Avs board. I became a pretty big Alex Tanguay fan during that time, so split my fandom between the two teams, but always said that no matter what the Blues fans deserved the cup the most and that's where my heart was. Blues fans from hockeyboards.com and later fanhome.com will probably remember me.
I was poor as shit in college and remember saving up my money and going to both Blues Round 1 games against the Sharks in 00. I drove 2 hours each way by myself. I thought that was the year we would win the cup. They ripped my heart out. The next year I went to the game four sweep against the Stars and both Avalanche/Blues WCF games - I was pretty torn during those games, but happy to see Tangers shine in Game 7 of the SCFs for Bourque.
Now that I'm in Chicago (since 03), I go see the boys whenever they're in town, and I try to get to a few games when I'm at home, too. It's nice to be in a sea of blue. I've traveled to watch the team as well and have been to Denver, Dallas, Glendale, San Jose, Buffalo, St. Paul, Detroit, Columbus, Pittsburgh, and Nashville. I've put a lot of time, money, and heart into this team. I haven't felt the way I do about this year's Blues team since 2000. I'm scared to death of having my heart ripped to pieces again. Game 3 nearly did me in. I've waited a long time. My hat is off to those of you that have been around since '67. My god, it's brutal.