He's one of the worse regular top 4 dmen I've seen in the modern era. I pay attention to him a lot and he looks like a forward playing defense. His positional awareness around the net is so bad, rookies are better than him. The worse part of this is that he has the physical tools now, he's strong and can knock guys off but he gets beat so friggin much. He's slow to rebounds and he doesn't protect the slot. Zaitsev might suck too but Zaitsev isn't that bad defensively, he's more of a victim of playing in a system ill-suited to him because he sucks at long strech passes.
Gardiner's worse flaw though is his play with the puck. For a puck moving dman, he is TERRIBLE at moving the puck. He doesn't rush it up the ice like Rielly, which is fine, not every guy does that. But the number of times he ices the puck or makes a bad pass in the neutral zone is inexcusable and should get most players demoted to the AHL. Especially those idiotic diagonal passes he makes, my word are they bad. Last night you saw how bad he was at making simple short passes within his own zone because the Bruins forecheck but even in games where we win and play well, he'll make multiple bad passes through the neutral zone and ice the puck or make a pass that the forward has no chance at handling.
I’m not a Gardiner supporter at all but why do most people only look at game 7. They had 3 other losses in that series. If the rest of the team stepped up maybe it wouldn’t have gone the distance. Everyone has bad games. Unfortunately his was a game 7.
He sucked the whole series game 7 was just an amplification.