Horvat or Reinhart - Who is Better Overall?

[Canucks LB]

Just having this Debate in another thread.

Click to read more...

 

[TeddyBare]

Over the last 3 seasons they are pretty close together

Sam Reinhart
GP: 205
Goals: 69
1st assist: 53
2nd assists: 33
total points: 155

Bo Horvat
GP: 207
Goals: 68
1st assist: 44
2nd assists: 41
total points: 153

Reinhart has the slight edge at even strength
Horvat generates more dangerous scoring chances

I'll vote horvat because 2 of those seasons his primary line mates were Loui Eriksson and Tanner Pearson
Reinhart had eichel as his center for 2 of his seasons.

Plus Horvat took the 1st most face-off's in the NHL during that time frame, and is elite at it.

I'm presuming the debate centered around would you trade Horvat for Reinhart?
I can't see Reinhart coming in and handling that workload that Horvat has
Horvat has taken 4800 face-offs in those 3 seasons (most in the league). Reinhart has taken 500 and spent most of that time at wing.

 

[lawrence]

Over the last 3 seasons they are pretty close together

Sam Reinhart
GP: 205
Goals: 69
1st assist: 53
2nd assists: 33
total points: 155

Bo Horvat
GP: 207
Goals: 68
1st assist: 44
2nd assists: 41
total points: 153

Reinhart has the slight edge at even strength
Horvat generates more dangerous scoring chances

I'll vote horvat because 2 of those seasons his primary line mates were Loui Eriksson and Tanner Pearson
Reinhart had eichel as his center for 2 of his seasons.

Plus Horvat took the 1st most face-off's in the NHL during that time frame, and is elite at it.

come to think of it, it's pretty pathetic Jim Benning didn't address the issue of getting Bo a solid winger to play a long side with. Tanner Pearson is meh, he did get to play with Hoglander but still I was expecting someone more proven oh right he traded away toffoli for nothing, riiiiiight.

 

[jetsforever]

Horvat

 

[Kreator]

close, but 53

 

[IPS]

Reinhart no question. Horvat is incredibly overrated and is more of a bottom-6 center IMO.

 

[Hockeyholic]

Reinhart no question. Horvat is incredibly overrated and is more of a bottom-6 center IMO.

Totally disagree.

Any team with Horvat as their #2C is in a great position.

 

[wetcoast]

come to think of it, it's pretty pathetic Jim Benning didn't address the issue of getting Bo a solid winger to play a long side with. Tanner Pearson is meh, he did get to play with Hoglander but still I was expecting someone more proven oh right he traded away toffoli for nothing, riiiiiight.

Sure enough but Bo isn't really a playmaking type of center either.

I take Bo easily here but Reinhart is a better player than some people around the league are giving him credit for.