Honest opinion on these prospects..

Status
Not open for further replies.

Debrincat93

Registered User
Dec 4, 2002
22,669
468
Michigan
Nhl.com
BobMarleyNYR said:
I hear ya, but avoid criticizing moderator decisions publicly - one of my many offenses.

it had nothing wrong in it, i just stated i cant believe 160 ppl would look at it and not say i word, thats all that was said, i dont understand why they would delete it, kinda pointless.. if it said some other stuff then lemme know cuz it was probably 5 in the morning and i was up for a while :dunno:
 

Ajacied

Stay strong Appie! ❤
Apr 6, 2002
25,135
911
Netherlands
BobMarleyNYR said:
Loui Eriksson - 3rd line two-way player, classic Finnish defensive forward.

1 - Eriksson's potential is higher than a 3rd line forward.
2 - He isn't Finnish
3 - He isn't a defensive forward
4 - Don't talk about players you know nothing about, Bob.
 

Preds666

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
7,321
359
Stefan Liv - decent career minor leaguer
Tobias Enstrom - very good career minor leaguer
Loui Eriksson - 2nd line NHL forward, 45 points/season | (ready in 2 years - (1 yr SEL, 1 yrr AHL))
Niklas Kronwall - No. 2 NHL-defenseman, 40-50 points/season (ready now)
Johan Franzen - 4th line NHL center. 5-20 points/season (ready now)
 

Legionnaire

Help On The Way
Jul 10, 2002
44,254
3,965
LA-LA Land
Chaos said:
Well since I criticized someone elses list(and managed to get my post deleted), I might as well throw my opinion out there:

Igor Grigorenko- 2nd line- 50-70 points
Jiri Hudler- 2nd line or bust(leaning toward bust simply because of his size)-50 pts
Valterri Filpulla- 3rd line- 20-40 points
Evan McGrath- 2nd/3rd line- 35-55 points
Stefan Liv- Barely average in NHL- plays in Sweden most of his career
Kyle Quincey- Dont know enough
Sean Bergenheim- 3rd line- 35 points
Dustin Brown- 1st/2nd line- 65-80 points
Alexander Picard (CBJ)-2nd/3rd line- 40-60 points
Konstantin Pushkaryev- 2nd line- 60 points
Konstantin Korneyev- Dont know enough
Tobias Enstrom- Dont know enough
Daivid Booth- Dont know enough
Loui Eriksson- 1st/2nd line- 55-70 points
Marc-Antoine Pouliot- 2nd/3rd line- 50-60 points
Marc-Andre Fleury- Good solid NHL starter
Niklas Kronwall- #3/4 dman, 30-40 points
Anton Babchuk- #2 dman, 20 points
Brent Seabrook- #3 dman, 30-40 points
Roman Voloshenko- 2nd/3rd liner, 40-60 points
Lukas Kaspar- 2nd/3rd liner, 50 points
Mikhail Grabovsky - 3rd liner, 30 points
Aki Seitsonen- Dont know enough
Brad Fast- Dont know enough
Darryl Bootland- Dont know enough
Johan Franzen- 3rd/4th liner, 25-35 points. Everyone is getting this guy wrong. Hes an overage(24 I think) Detroit forward prospect, not the Stars defenseman Johan Fransson.

I think I like your list better.
 

Debrincat93

Registered User
Dec 4, 2002
22,669
468
Michigan
Nhl.com
Legionnaire said:
I think I like your list better.

i like everything but kronwall, kronny will be a 2-3 defensemen, only time hell be a 4 is this year if that... he could step in and outplay fischer and hatcher, and we dont have schneider anymore

Predatore said:
Stefan Liv - decent career minor leaguer
Tobias Enstrom - very good career minor leaguer
Loui Eriksson - 2nd line NHL forward, 45 points/season | (ready in 2 years - (1 yr SEL, 1 yrr AHL))
Niklas Kronwall - No. 2 NHL-defenseman, 40-50 points/season (ready now)
Johan Franzen - 4th line NHL center. 5-20 points/season (ready now)

45 pts on the 2nd line for loui, little low dont you think? id see something more like 50-60 pts for him on the 2nd line
 

Legionnaire

Help On The Way
Jul 10, 2002
44,254
3,965
LA-LA Land
zetterberg40 said:
i like everything but kronwall, kronny will be a 2-3 defensemen, only time hell be a 4 is this year if that... he could step in and outplay fischer and hatcher, and we dont have schneider anymore



45 pts on the 2nd line for loui, little low dont you think? id see something more like 50-60 pts for him on the 2nd line

Any opinions on Bootland? I liked what I saw last year. A tough guy who could chip in a couple of goals every now and again.
 

salty justice

Registered User
May 25, 2004
7,194
0
Los Angeles
CrossCheck said:
That would be sad if your #2 gets only 20 pts a saeson!

Either he's #2 and gets 30 - 35 pts or top 4 with 20 pts... Please!

I guess Scott Stevens must be a #4 dman, averaging less than 20 points over the last 3 years.
 

Chaos

And the winner is...
Sep 2, 2003
7,968
18
TX
CrossCheck said:
That would be sad if your #2 gets only 20 pts a saeson!

Either he's #2 and gets 30 - 35 pts or top 4 with 20 pts... Please!

He's more of a defensive guy than one who will put up the points. Hell, Hatcher was arguably the Stars #1 d-man for several years, and he barely broke 30 points(31 being his high).
 

Vatican Roulette

Baile de Los Locos
Feb 28, 2002
14,007
2
Gorillaz-EPWRID
Visit site
Legionnaire said:
Any opinions on Bootland? I liked what I saw last year. A tough guy who could chip in a couple of goals every now and again.


He's a punching bag that can ship in every 20 games or so. I was happy when they called him up, thrilled when i saw him go out there like McCarty, crashing and banging.

then...it stopped. He wasn't as physical, took stupid penalties, and got sent down. He improved his point totals this year in the AHL, but its iffy if the wings are going to re-sign him.
 

Debrincat93

Registered User
Dec 4, 2002
22,669
468
Michigan
Nhl.com
Legionnaire said:
Any opinions on Bootland? I liked what I saw last year. A tough guy who could chip in a couple of goals every now and again.

eh, good stint at the beginning with the big team, then died down, started just playing hockey and not being an enforcer and give us spunk like he started to do and what we wanted him to do, he wasnt fighting or helping turn momentum like what avery or mccarty used to do for us, so he was thrown back down... if he comes up and sticks to being a enforcer, could be a good one, then he might throw up about 10-15 pts a year, but over 200 pims for sure
 

Vipers

Registered User
May 17, 2002
147
0
Visit site
Don't know if Fleury will turn out to be the best goalie in the NHL.
He has the potential to do it, at least to be a top five.
And he has 2 years of experience in the AHL and NHL at 20 y. old only.
He is on the way to be NHL ready in 06-07(1 more year in AHL)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->