TheDevilMadeMe
Registered User
He's as dominant as Cleghorn. Each was clearly the best at their position. It's really tough to say one was significantly better than the other. In any case, I don't feel that strongly about any player to argue about it. All I said was that they could be "arguably" better than Nighbor, as in, it's not completely absurd.
I'd vote for Benedict over Cleghorn because I think he was more of a "winner."
Regardless, Benedict, Cleghorn, and Malone are likely to be 3 of my next 4 (as in the 2nd vote).
I just don't know if either Benedict or Cleghorn was considered to be quite as big a star as Nighbor during the era.
Last edited: