BenchBrawl
Registered User
- Jul 26, 2010
- 30,907
- 13,716
Round 1 list
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Sprague Cleghorn at 3rd (tied with 2 others)
Jack Darragh at 33rd
Fred Scanlan at 47th
Art Gagne at 52nd (tied with 1 other)
Withey Merritt at 57th
Clare McKerrow at 64th
Doc Stewart at 66th
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Only list without Joe Hall
Only list without Tommy Smith
Si Griffis at 67th (tied with 1 other)
Gordon Roberts at 78th
Players from our final Top 70 not ranked on this list
Joe Hall
Tommy Smith
Harry Oliver
Lloyd Cook
Weldy Young
Dick Irvin
Jack Campbell
Jack Adams
Dickie Boon
Players unique to this list
Doc Stewart
Round 2 Voting Record
1 | Frank Nighbor |
2 | Cyclone Taylor |
3 | Sprague Cleghorn |
4 | Georges Vezina |
5 | Newsy Lalonde |
6 | Clint Benedict |
7 | Joe Malone |
8 | Cy Denneny |
9 | Tommy Phillips |
10 | Eddie Gerard |
11 | Hugh Lehman |
12 | Hod Stuart |
13 | Frank McGee |
14 | Georges Boucher |
15 | Russell Bowie |
16 | Moose Johnson |
17 | Frank Fredrickson |
18 | Harry Cameron |
19 | Mickey MacKay |
20 | Hap Holmes |
21 | Frank Foyston |
22 | Babe Dye |
23 | Didier Pitre |
24 | Duke Keats |
25 | Lester Patrick |
26 | Herb Gardiner |
27 | Jack Walker |
28 | Joe Simpson |
29 | George Hay |
30 | Percy Lesueur |
31 | Tommy Dunderdale |
32 | Mike Grant |
33 | Jack Darragh |
34 | Art Ross |
35 | Bernie Morris |
36 | Harvey Pulford |
37 | Frank Patrick |
38 | Art Duncan |
39 | Paddy Moran |
40 | Punch Broadbent |
41 | Dan Bain |
42 | Jack Marshall |
43 | Reg Noble |
44 | Carson Cooper |
45 | Harry Trihey |
46 | Alf Smith |
47 | Fred Scanlan |
48 | Eddie Oatman |
49 | Bouse Hutton |
50 | Smokey Harris |
51 | George McNamara |
52 | Art Gagne |
53 | Bobby Rowe |
54 | Marty Walsh |
55 | Riley Hern |
56 | Odie Cleghorn |
57 | Whitey Merritt |
58 | Barney Stanley |
59 | Billy Nicholson |
60 | Bob McDougall |
61 | Haviland Routh |
62 | Harry Hyland |
63 | Graham Drinkwater |
64 | Clare McKerrow |
65 | Harry Smith |
66 | Doc Stewart |
67 | Si Griffis |
68 | Tom Paton |
69 | Art Farrell |
70 | Allan Cameron |
71 | Dubbie Kerr |
72 | Jimmy Gardner |
73 | Harry Watson |
74 | Harry Westwick |
75 | Dolly Swift |
76 | Ernie Russell |
77 | Blair Russell |
78 | Gord Roberts |
79 | Hobey Baker |
80 | Bruce Stuart |
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Sprague Cleghorn at 3rd (tied with 2 others)
Jack Darragh at 33rd
Fred Scanlan at 47th
Art Gagne at 52nd (tied with 1 other)
Withey Merritt at 57th
Clare McKerrow at 64th
Doc Stewart at 66th
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Only list without Joe Hall
Only list without Tommy Smith
Si Griffis at 67th (tied with 1 other)
Gordon Roberts at 78th
Players from our final Top 70 not ranked on this list
Joe Hall
Tommy Smith
Harry Oliver
Lloyd Cook
Weldy Young
Dick Irvin
Jack Campbell
Jack Adams
Dickie Boon
Players unique to this list
Doc Stewart
Round 2 Voting Record
| Vote 1 | Vote 2 | Vote 3 | Vote 4 | Vote 5 | Vote 6 | Vote 7 | Vote 8 | Vote 9 | Vote 10 | Vote 11 | Vote 12 | Vote 13 | Vote 14 |
| Nighbor | Lehman | Lehman | McGee | H. Cameron | Hay | Bain | Walker | Hall | Go. Roberts | Routh | Boon | Boon | Westwick |
| Taylor | Malone | H. Stuart | M. Johnson | Hay | Pitre | W. Young | Tom. Smith | F. Patrick | Duncan | Broadbent | Westwick | Westwick | Oatman |
| Lalonde | Benedict | Fredrickson | Keats | Dye | Ross | A. Smith | Moran | Irvin | Routh | A. Cameron | Swift | Trihey | J. Adams |
| Bowie | Gerard | G. Boucher | L. Patrick | Grant | Lesueur | Walker | J. Campbell | Go.Roberts | Broadbent | Westwick | Trihey | Oatman | D. Kerr |
| S. Cleghorn | Fredrickson | McGee | MacKay | Pitre | Bain | Tom. Smith | Morris | Dunderdale | H. Oliver | Swift | Cooper | J. Adams | Darragh |
| Phillips | Cy Denneny | Cy Denneny | H. Cameron | Ross | Walker | Moran | H. Gardiner | Noble | Walsh | Trihey | Oatman | D. Kerr | O. Cleghorn |
| Vezina | Phillips | M.Johnson | Foyston | Lesueur | Holmes | Morris | Hall | Duncan | Trihey | Cooper | J. Adams | O. Cleghorn | Hern |
| Gerard | M. Johnson | L. Patrick | Hay | Walker | Morris | H. Gardiner | Go. Roberts | Routh | E. Russell | E. Russell | D. Kerr | Hern | Hyland |
| H. Stuart | H. Stuart | MacKay | Dye | Pulford | Dunderdale | Hall | F. Patrick | Broadbent | Oatman | Oatman | O. Cleghorn | Hyland | Shir. Davidson |
| Benedict | MacKay | H. Cameron | Grant | Holmes | Hall | Dunderdale | Duncan | H. Oliver | J. Marshall | J. Marshall | Hern | S. Harris | B. Russell |
