BenchBrawl
Registered User
- Jul 26, 2010
- 30,907
- 13,718
Round 1 list
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Sprague Cleghorn at 3rd
Reg Noble at 18th
Herb Gardiner at 25th (tied with 2 others)
Joe Hall at 26th
Dolly Swift at 37th
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Si Griffis at 67th (tied with 1 other)
Players from our final Top 70 not ranked on this list
Harry Oliver
Bob McDougall
Dick Irvin
Carson Cooper
Harry Trihey
Dickie Boon
Dubbie Kerr
Players unique to this list
none
Round 2 Voting Record
1 | Frank Nighbor |
2 | Cyclone Taylor |
3 | Sprague Cleghorn |
4 | Newsy Lalonde |
5 | Georges Vezina |
6 | Joe Malone |
7 | Cy Denneny |
8 | Hod Stuart |
9 | Clint Benedict |
10 | Eddie Gerard |
11 | Russell Bowie |
12 | Georges Boucher |
13 | Tommy Phillips |
14 | Moose Johnson |
15 | Harvey Pulford |
16 | Harry Cameron |
17 | Babe Dye |
18 | Reg Noble |
19 | Mickey MacKay |
20 | Didier Pitre |
21 | Lester Patrick |
22 | Mike Grant |
23 | Frank Foyston |
24 | Jack Walker |
25 | Herb Gardiner |
26 | Joe Hall |
27 | Frank Fredrickson |
28 | Frank McGee |
29 | Duke Keats |
30 | Marty Walsh |
31 | Hugh Lehman |
32 | Art Ross |
33 | Tommy Dunderdale |
34 | George Hay |
35 | Joe Simpson |
36 | Art Duncan |
37 | Dolly Swift |
38 | Punch Broadbent |
39 | Blair Russell |
40 | Frank Patrick |
41 | Hap Holmes |
42 | Lloyd Cook |
43 | Smokey Harris |
44 | Bernie Morris |
45 | Dan Bain |
46 | Percy Lesueur |
47 | Barney Stanley |
48 | Alf Smith |
49 | Gord Roberts |
50 | Ernie Russell |
51 | Weldy Young |
52 | Tom Paton |
53 | Eddie Oatman |
54 | Harry Hyland |
55 | Odie Cleghorn |
56 | Jack Adams |
57 | Jack Darragh |
58 | Tommy Smith |
59 | Paddy Moran |
60 | Scotty Davidson |
61 | Jack Campbell |
62 | Art Gagne |
63 | Allan Cameron |
64 | Howard McNamara |
65 | Bobby Rowe |
66 | Jack Marshall |
67 | Si Griffis |
68 | Riley Hern |
69 | Hamby Shore |
70 | Graham Drinkwater |
71 | Goldie Prodgers |
72 | Bruce Stuart |
73 | George McNamara |
74 | Harry Smith |
75 | Harry Westwick |
76 | Bouse Hutton |
77 | Corb Denneny |
78 | Moose Goheen |
79 | Cully Wilson |
80 | Haviland Routh |
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Sprague Cleghorn at 3rd
Reg Noble at 18th
Herb Gardiner at 25th (tied with 2 others)
Joe Hall at 26th
Dolly Swift at 37th
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Si Griffis at 67th (tied with 1 other)
Players from our final Top 70 not ranked on this list
Harry Oliver
Bob McDougall
Dick Irvin
Carson Cooper
Harry Trihey
Dickie Boon
Dubbie Kerr
Players unique to this list
none
Round 2 Voting Record
| Vote 1 | Vote 2 | Vote 3 | Vote 4 | Vote 5 | Vote 6 | Vote 7 | Vote 8 | Vote 9 | Vote 10 | Vote 11 | Vote 12 | Vote 13 | Vote 14 |
| Nighbor | Gerard | H. Stuart | M. Johnson | H. Cameron | A. Smith | Walker | Noble | Duncan | Cooper | S. Harris | D. Kerr | ||
| Taylor | H. Stuart | Cy Denneny | L. Patrick | Pitre | Walker | Noble | Hall | Go. Roberts | S. Harris | Hyland | S. Harris | ||
| S. Cleghorn | Malone | G. Boucher | Keats | Dye | W. Young | H. Gardiner | Duncan | J. Marshall | Hyland | Ha. Smith | Hyland | ||
| Vezina | Cy Denneny | Lehman | Pitre | Hay | Bain | Hall | Go.Roberts | L. Cook | Ha. Smith | Westwick | Ha. Smith | ||
| Lalonde | Benedict | Fredrickson | MacKay | Foyston | Noble | Moran | Dunderdale | Walsh | Swift | Stanley | Westwick | ||
| Gerard | Phillips | M.Johnson | Dye | Ross | Simpson | J. Campbell | J. Marshall | E. Russell | Westwick | Boon | Stanley | ||
| H. Stuart | G. Boucher | L. Patrick | Hay | Morris | H. Gardiner | Duncan | L.Cook | Cooper | Stanley | J. Adams | J. Adams | ||
| Cy Denneny | Lehman | Keats | McGee | Dunderdale | Hall | Go. Roberts | Walsh | Routh | D. Kerr | Paton | Darragh | ||
| Bowie | M. Johnson | Pitre | H. Cameron | Grant | Tom. Smith | Morris | F. Patrick | S. Harris | Hutton | Darragh | Oatman | ||
| Malone | Dye | Dye | Foyston | Walker | Morris | Tom. Smith | MacDougall | Hyland | J. Adams | D. Kerr | Shir. Davidson |
