Hockey Prospectus 2011 NHL Organization Rankings

[8spokesontheB]

What are your thoughts on the rankings? Link:http://www.hockeyprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=1012

The author's name is "Pronman". Nomme de plume?

 

[hockeyball]

It's a terrible article. Detroit 1st and the Sharks dead last pretty much tells the story. Sharks prospect pool isn't fantastic right now, but we have a lot of players expected to make the NHL at some level and some pretty excellent goalie and defense prospects. We are weak at forward, but stacked everywhere else. Hardly worst in the league.

NHL Potential:
Forwards:
Nieto
Viedensky
Wingels
Mashinter
McCarthy
Ferriero
McClaren
Sgarbosa

Defense:
Bruan
Doherty
Petrecki
Wrenn
Irwin
Albetshauser
Moore

Goaltending:
Greiss
Stalock
Sateri
JP Anderson

No blue chips, but a lot of solid players.

 

[TaketheCannoli]

This read like a fanboy article. I can't believe this guy wants to charge money for amateurish writing that even includes bad grammar.

 

[Nuckles]

Unbelievably bad article.

 

[Benedict Kovalchuk]

I saw Detroit at #1 and the Islanders at #2 and stopped reading after that.

 

[feds91]

Red Wings fan here and I completely totally 100% disagree with the Wings being ranked 1st. awful list!

 

[His Beardliness*]

It's a terrible article. Detroit 1st and the Sharks dead last pretty much tells the story. Sharks prospect pool isn't fantastic right now, but we have a lot of players expected to make the NHL at some level and some pretty excellent goalie and defense prospects. We are weak at forward, but stacked everywhere else. Hardly worst in the league.

NHL Potential:
Forwards:
Nieto
Viedensky
Wingels
Mashinter
McCarthy
Ferriero
McClaren
Sgarbosa

Defense:
Bruan
Doherty
Petrecki
Wrenn
Irwin
Albetshauser
Moore

Goaltending:
Greiss
Stalock
Sateri
JP Anderson

No blue chips, but a lot of solid players.

Uh no, the sharks are pretty much dead last unless you're a huge homer. Detroit should not be #1 though. Ottawa should.

 

[AUAIOMRN]

This has been discussed in the Prospect forum.

http://hfboards.com/showthread.php?t=950099