OT: HFNYR Boardies pls 2014-15: Tanner Steel Award for Most Underrated Poster

[5 4 Fighting]

I love Fish, and I miss Callagraves, and for sure Tawnos is the man

But for me, it's hands down Mikos, an interesting cat who's posts I love to read.

BBKers is an interesting one as well a bit too interesting sometimes

 

[Kokoschka]

Was wondering why I wasn't on the poll. But it's not okay!!

I was wondering why you weren't in the poll too. Seriously. Cwede is very good as well, when he decides to post.

 

[nyrleetch]

Silverfish.... but if he wins, does this mean he's not underrated?

 

[Beer League Sniper]

Write-in for eco's bones. That dude is just an incredibly solid poster, with well thought out and respectful opinions.

 

[JohnC]

I had a nomination...

http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showpost.php?p=103447693&postcount=75

This is how underrated I am

 

[darko]

Silverfish.... but if he wins, does this mean he's not underrated?

Yes.

 

[silverfish]

Silverfish.... but if he wins, does this mean he's not underrated?

Yes.

Perhaps next time, you will rate me

(I know that's not the quote, just play along people, jeez)

 

[bernmeister]

I Eat Crow, in a close one.

 

[Ex Officer Friendly]

Question.... or more so a suggestion.

Why aren't these votes like kept secretly? Think that it's more fair (and suspenseful) that no one knows who votes for who, you know?

It's also a little more mature. I mean, would you tell people which candidate you chose for Presidency?

Like the Presidency you can be free to tell people who you voted for on here as well, it is not a requirement to vote in the poll and then tell everyone who you voted for.

Unless you see something i dont see?

 

[nyrleetch]

I had a nomination...

http://hfboards.mandatory.com/showpost.php?p=103447693&postcount=75

This is how underrated I am

We've found the frontrunner for next years vote.

 

[Inferno]

if you win, are you the most overrated of the underrated posters here?

hmm...

 

[SingnBluesOnBroadway]

if you win, are you the most overrated of the underrated posters here?

hmm...

That's the Kevin Klein award.

 

[McRanger]

if you win, are you the most overrated of the underrated posters here?

hmm...

If you win you are the most adequately rated poster.

I voted for you Inferno. I have always found you sufficiently adequate.

 

[Inferno]

If you win you are the most adequately rated poster.

I voted for you Inferno. I have always found you sufficiently adequate.

why thank you. thats what my father in law said when i married his daughter.

 

[PlamsUnlimited]

Question.... or more so a suggestion.

Why aren't these votes like kept secretly? Think that it's more fair (and suspenseful) that no one knows who votes for who, you know?

It's also a little more mature. I mean, would you tell people which candidate you chose for Presidency?

Cause it's an Internet forum.

 

[PlamsUnlimited]

Also appreciate the usage of my name for Tanner

 

[Miamipuck]

Miamipuck.

Thank you Matt and to everyone who voted/nominated me, I sincerely appreciate it.


I will not vote for myself, whoever wants my vote can PM me and I will give you the requisite payment requirements, my vote doesn't come cheap.

 

[Synergy27]

I voted for Silverfish, but regret it now that I know that's the mainstream choice. From underrated to overrated in one thread - the epitome of HFBoards.

 

[Joey Bones]

Like the Presidency you can be free to tell people who you voted for on here as well, it is not a requirement to vote in the poll and then tell everyone who you voted for.

Unless you see something i dont see?

 

[CTRanger]

For me this is Tawnos or Mikos all day. Always informative with educated opinions.

 

[YoSoyLalo]

Question.... or more so a suggestion.

Why aren't these votes like kept secretly? Think that it's more fair (and suspenseful) that no one knows who votes for who, you know?

It's also a little more mature. I mean, would you tell people which candidate you chose for Presidency?

Yes, what reason would I have not to?

 

[Mikos87]

I love Fish, and I miss Callagraves, and for sure Tawnos is the man

But for me, it's hands down Mikos, an interesting cat who's posts I love to read.

BBKers is an interesting one as well a bit too interesting sometimes

For me this is Tawnos or Mikos all day. Always informative with educated opinions.

Haha thank you guys! Appreciate the support. Can't believe I got more than a single vote.

 

[Sirius Vivace]

There will not be many more votes, so I feel I can say this without really affecting the outcome. In regards to the two members in the lead:

To me, the new poster that I am..... Mikos & Silverfish have always stood out. In my mind, they command respect and are in no way underrated. Mikos is fantastic in all aspects, from Europe, to minor N.A. leagues ... to the NHL. He simply knows his stuff....as though he may have played the game. I assumed everyone else realized this as well.

Regarding Silverfish, he's a unique poster, indeed. Not only does he appear to have a good grasp on the game...but his approach to stats is refreshing. He's not a zealot in favor of stats, but has a good handle on them and is adept at putting them to the "context test". When others don't know how to argue the results of an advanced stat...Silverfish will find the weak spot in whatever assumption has made...and will use another advanced stat to question the opposing argument. A true intellectual...and I'm jealous, lol.

In any case, don't take this as a complaint. It's a compliment to these guys. I've always found these two guys to be exceptional. I didn't realize others have considered them to be flying "under our radar".

 

[Hunter Gathers]

Fish is also awesome on the ASOIAF thread in the Lounge.

 

[silverfish]

Fish is also awesome on the ASOIAF thread in the Lounge.

ASOIAF. Fancystats.

All-around nerd.

**** Olly for real though.