Help with Trade evaluation

[Khobahi]

Side 1

Pavelski
Phaneuf

Side 2

E.Staal
Semin
Byfuglien

Pretty much every stat is in the league (G, A, +/-, PIM, PPG, PPA, SHG, SHA, GWG, FW, SOG, BLK, HIT)

which side wins this?

Click to read more...

 

[Wiqkid*]

Side 2 EASY. Staal and Semin will bounce back and I rather have buff than dion anyways.

 

[Khobahi]

I just dont have much hope for Carolina atm.... this would also free up a spot for me to throw A.Vermette into my line up.... not sure..

 

[Boreal01]

I'm leaning towards side 1 but side 2 also gets pretty good return.

 

[Kardi]

Who would you drop if you accepted side 2 (or pick up for side one)

 

[Khobahi]

The way i have structured it (i currently own side 2 and would receive side 1)

He can drop whoever or add whoever off his bench to make the trade happen.

I would put Pavelski in my RW slow (C,RW eligibility) Phaneuf in Byfs spot. and then in the open center spot from Staal i could put in A.Vermette or T.Hertl from my bench (most likely the former). I would end up with either his throwaway player or another roster spot to pick someone up.

 

[ResilientBeast]

The way i have structured it (i currently own side 2 and would receive side 1)

He can drop whoever or add whoever off his bench to make the trade happen.

I would put Pavelski in my RW slow (C,RW eligibility) Phaneuf in Byfs spot. and then in the open center spot from Staal i could put in A.Vermette or T.Hertl from my bench (most likely the former). I would end up with either his throwaway player or another roster spot to pick someone up.

I really wouldn't do it, Staal is perennially a slow starter and since Semin is lining up with him Semin's numbers have taken a hit.

Byfuglien with hits and blocks is an amazingly valuable d man.


Don't do the deal I really don't like it for you and no waiver wire pick up will make it close.

 

[NYR89]

I would keep Staal/Semin and Buff.

 

[bleedblue1223]

Keep option 2. Don't sell low, they will bounce back.

 

[Khobahi]

i guess... my team is just super underperforming atm and getting really annoyed..

Normally E.Kane is in the spot Hertl is in.

just not sure what to do lol (in 9th of 10...)