Speculation: Head Coach Hunt 2021

Status
Not open for further replies.

rt

The Kinder, Gentler Version
May 13, 2004
96,890
45,263
A Rockwellian Pleasantville
Of the commonly mentioned candidates, it’s Rocky Thompson for me. And it’s not even really close. All the others are either underwhelming or totally unappealing.

I am not including guys like Knoblauch as I have not seen his name raised outside of HF.

Edit: Quinn ahead of Thompson if it includes Eichel.
I like Thompson the best, too. I’ll go further and say that I’ve become a Thompson fan through this. Even if the Coyotes don’t hire him, I’m going to be following his career and cheering for him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baby Doaner

Mosby

<3 Uncle Gary
Feb 16, 2012
23,378
18,083
Toronto
It’s interesting how Thompson and Tocchet were basically the same player but are wildly different coaches. Would Tocchet be where Thompson is now had he taken a similar coaching path?

In hindsight Rick Tocchet going EIGHT years between head coaching gigs should have been our first clue. That’s basically unheard of.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Canis Latrans

XX

Waiting for Ishbia
Dec 10, 2002
54,886
14,502
PHX
Tocchet never put in the time anywhere in the lower leagues as a HC. It really showed in him not really understanding the basics of things like ingame adjustments and goalie/timeout management. Great head coaches tend to be studious and understand everything going on tactically, even if they delegate or relinquish control entirely. He never improved over the years, so he might just peak at excellent cheerleader/good cop. It's telling that Tocchet is not noted for any tactical acumen, only being able to talk with players. You got the sense he desperately needed his assistants to carry the load in a way other coaches didn't.

I like that Thompson can give a talk that gets the notice of other pro level coaches. He doesn't have any sacred cows because he doesn't have that luxury. If he finds a better way, he'll use it, no questions asked. And the upside with regards to holding on to the room there isn't compromised in any way either. Guys love him. Teams tuned Rick out after the first month or so when he failed to make adjustments and they'd just run into the same wall over and over again. He only really knows how to poorly mimic how the Pens play and that's it.

I can't really think of a better cheap (read: likely) candidate with less risk at this point than Thompson.
 

rt

The Kinder, Gentler Version
May 13, 2004
96,890
45,263
A Rockwellian Pleasantville
I am not including guys like Knoblauch as I have not seen his name raised outside of HF.
Scott Burnside mentioned him in the Athletic:

Who could the Coyotes target?
Burnside: A bumpy ride so far for Armstrong and this coaching hire is critical in helping a core of promising young players like Chychrun, Christian Dvorak and Clayton Keller become leaders and create a culture of winning. Bruce Boudreau is as good a regular-season coach as you’ll find anywhere. Want younger? Jay Woodcroft has done a nice job in AHL Bakersfield. Kris Knoblauch, if he doesn't get tabbed to fill the Ranger job, is an up-and-coming young hockey mind.

Arizona Coyotes, head coach Rick Tocchet part ways
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mosby

Canis Latrans

Registered User
Jan 19, 2015
1,229
951
Australia
It’s interesting how Thompson and Tocchet were basically the same player but are wildly different coaches. Would Tocchet be where Thompson is now had he taken a similar coaching path?

In hindsight Rick Tocchet going EIGHT years between head coaching gigs should have been our first clue. That’s basically unheard of.
Rick Bowness has. He served as head coach for the Islanders prior to coming here to be an assistant and then took over in 2003-04 for 20 games when Francis was let go. He then stayed as an assistant until taking over from Montgomery last season. That's a huge gap of 15 years, and would be 22 had he not been an interim here. To be fair though, he made the Finals in Dallas as interim and so they kind of had to keep him. I think under normal circumstances, there would have been zero chance that any team would hire him or offer him an interview, so your point is well taken.
 

Grimes

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jan 5, 2012
8,437
4,802
Tippet's Doghouse
Of the commonly mentioned candidates, it’s Rocky Thompson for me. And it’s not even really close. All the others are either underwhelming or totally unappealing.

I am not including guys like Knoblauch as I have not seen his name raised outside of HF.

Edit: Quinn ahead of Thompson if it includes Eichel.

Agreed:
Tier 1
Rocky/Quonn
Tier 2
Nelson/MVR
Tier 3
The rest of em
 

cobra427

Registered User
May 6, 2012
9,327
3,347
Tocchet never put in the time anywhere in the lower leagues as a HC. It really showed in him not really understanding the basics of things like ingame adjustments and goalie/timeout management. Great head coaches tend to be studious and understand everything going on tactically, even if they delegate or relinquish control entirely. He never improved over the years, so he might just peak at excellent cheerleader/good cop. It's telling that Tocchet is not noted for any tactical acumen, only being able to talk with players. You got the sense he desperately needed his assistants to carry the load in a way other coaches didn't.

I like that Thompson can give a talk that gets the notice of other pro level coaches. He doesn't have any sacred cows because he doesn't have that luxury. If he finds a better way, he'll use it, no questions asked. And the upside with regards to holding on to the room there isn't compromised in any way either. Guys love him. Teams tuned Rick out after the first month or so when he failed to make adjustments and they'd just run into the same wall over and over again. He only really knows how to poorly mimic how the Pens play and that's it.

I can't really think of a better cheap (read: likely) candidate with less risk at this point than Thompson.
RT was a leader as a player, he did that by his play on the ice and his attitude. As a coach, he tried to befriend the players fist, then be a leader second, leadership does not work that way. You can see all this in the Morgan sit down, it has little to do with his tactics, lines or decisions, he just couldn't get the players to follow him. Our next coach needs to be a leader above all else.
 

Jakey53

Registered User
Aug 27, 2011
29,978
9,040
  • How often does a wet under the ears hire a top tier veteran coach. Would a Torts or Quinn even want to work w BA, not even taking into account the Arizona tire fire?
Tire fire? Chayka screwed us and we are moving forward. Not many HCing jobs in the NHL so most of the people mentioned would jump at the chance to be one. The experienced proven HC can be more choosey and can wait for the right opening and $$$.
 

Bonsai Tree

Turning a new leaf
Feb 2, 2014
9,180
4,462
Tire fire? Chayka screwed us and we are moving forward. Not many HCing jobs in the NHL so most of the people mentioned would jump at the chance to be one. The experienced proven HC can be more choosey and can wait for the right opening and $$$.
Tire fire.
 

rt

The Kinder, Gentler Version
May 13, 2004
96,890
45,263
A Rockwellian Pleasantville
I’m going to give BA the benefit of the doubt on his hire. But if he hires one of the guys I happen to like the most, I’ll feel all the better about it. BA continues to do the things I want him to do, just on a more patient and conservative timeline than I want. Which is a good thing. If I was GM the entire roster would turn over twice per season. Lol. I’m very hopeful that his head coach pick will be a good one.
 

BUX7PHX

Registered User
Jul 7, 2011
5,581
1,350
My only question with coaching is where are our players at?

What I mean by that is we have some young talent. I think even BA was saying that he acknowledged having a little more depth in the system than realized. So, we should have a lot of players whom the front office controls for a while. This is inclusive of all of those long term deals that were by Keller, Chychrun, etc.

Is our team the type that right now is getting the most out of its players? If we still have enough players who learned a bad system of Tocchet's, how much more/better teaching is needed? Thompson sounds like the type if we need more teaching. There's a big part of me that wants to say that the team has grown up to where less teaching/instruction is necessary and now we need more of the psychological type who knows how to get people to perform.

I guess I am asking, what is the biggest piece to the puzzle that we need our coach to add? Because we can hire the guy for all the right reasons, and still achieve poor results.
 

rt

The Kinder, Gentler Version
May 13, 2004
96,890
45,263
A Rockwellian Pleasantville
My only question with coaching is where are our players at?

What I mean by that is we have some young talent. I think even BA was saying that he acknowledged having a little more depth in the system than realized. So, we should have a lot of players whom the front office controls for a while. This is inclusive of all of those long term deals that were by Keller, Chychrun, etc.

Is our team the type that right now is getting the most out of its players? If we still have enough players who learned a bad system of Tocchet's, how much more/better teaching is needed? Thompson sounds like the type if we need more teaching. There's a big part of me that wants to say that the team has grown up to where less teaching/instruction is necessary and now we need more of the psychological type who knows how to get people to perform.

I guess I am asking, what is the biggest piece to the puzzle that we need our coach to add? Because we can hire the guy for all the right reasons, and still achieve poor results.
Under Tocchet, our team has been soft, sluggish, unprepared and shrunk in the big moments.

We need a leader. The best leader of men we can find. I think BA recognizes this. He keeps saying a young guy with “energy” who can give us the “push” we need. Then he inevitably starts talking all about leadership.

For my money, that’s Rocky Thompson, hands down.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cobra427

cobra427

Registered User
May 6, 2012
9,327
3,347
Under Tocchet, our team has been soft, sluggish, unprepared and shrunk in the big moments.

We need a leader. The best leader of men we can find. I think BA recognizes this. He keeps saying a young guy with “energy” who can give us the “push” we need. Then he inevitably starts talking all about leadership.

For my money, that’s Rocky Thompson, hands down.
I agree, its all about hiring a leader. I like Rocky as well, BA will vet them all out.
 

Jakey53

Registered User
Aug 27, 2011
29,978
9,040
I’m going to give BA the benefit of the doubt on his hire. But if he hires one of the guys I happen to like the most, I’ll feel all the better about it. BA continues to do the things I want him to do, just on a more patient and conservative timeline than I want. Which is a good thing. If I was GM the entire roster would turn over twice per season. Lol. I’m very hopeful that his head coach pick will be a good one.
You are like Chayka. Look how that turned out.
 

Jakey53

Registered User
Aug 27, 2011
29,978
9,040
Under Tocchet, our team has been soft, sluggish, unprepared and shrunk in the big moments.

We need a leader. The best leader of men we can find. I think BA recognizes this. He keeps saying a young guy with “energy” who can give us the “push” we need. Then he inevitably starts talking all about leadership.

For my money, that’s Rocky Thompson, hands down.
Unfortunately, "the best leader we can find" are none of the ones mentioned. Most are unproven at the NHL level.
 

Jakey53

Registered User
Aug 27, 2011
29,978
9,040
I agree, its all about hiring a leader. I like Rocky as well, BA will vet them all out.
It's easy to be a manager and a leader of one restaurant, quite another to be promoted to general manger and control 20 restaurants and have the same success. Not saying it can't be done, but I don't want my coach needing training wheels on my dime. Of all the names talked about, Quinn seems the most qualified but he was fired for missing the playoffs which may or may not have been his fault as we don't have any inside info. Interesting times.
 

cobra427

Registered User
May 6, 2012
9,327
3,347
No its' not. Just because you have success at a lower level and are know for a good leader does not mean it will translate to a higher level.
The safest bet is somebody proven Gallant/Torts type, previous success at multiple stops. We are going to hire somebody that has had success at some level, we know that, but that doesn't mean they were a good leader. I would look past the success and dive into leadership qualities. Does BA know what to look for and what questions to ask? Maybe, I hope so. Chayka wouldn't know, he had no leadership experience or training in that area. This is a pretty sophisticated and nuanced topic, I just hope BA picks the right coach (good leader), it will do wonders for our team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jakey53

cobra427

Registered User
May 6, 2012
9,327
3,347
It's easy to be a manager and a leader of one restaurant, quite another to be promoted to general manger and control 20 restaurants and have the same success. Not saying it can't be done, but I don't want my coach needing training wheels on my dime. Of all the names talked about, Quinn seems the most qualified but he was fired for missing the playoffs which may or may not have been his fault as we don't have any inside info. Interesting times.
Just because you managed a business or restaurant and had some success, it doesn't mean you are a good leader, there is a big difference. I agree, if you had success on a smaller scale, it doesn't translate to success at a higher level. Leadership skills do transfer though, I would look for that in a hire.
 

rt

The Kinder, Gentler Version
May 13, 2004
96,890
45,263
A Rockwellian Pleasantville
Just because you managed a business or restaurant and had some success, it doesn't mean you are a good leader, there is a big difference. I agree, if you had success on a smaller scale, it doesn't translate to success at a higher level. Leadership skills do transfer though, I would look for that in a hire.
THANK YOU!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Summer Rose

Mosby

<3 Uncle Gary
Feb 16, 2012
23,378
18,083
Toronto
This board wants to build a monument to Dave Tippett. Well, in 2002, Dave Tippett became a first-time NHL head coach at 41 years old. He took the job with 3 years experience as an NHL assistant coach and 4 years experience as a minor-pro head coach. As a first-year NHL head coach, he then led the Stars to 111 points and the second round of the playoffs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->