Hall of Fame Game

[Cassano]

Miggy is a no doubter

Dustin Pedroia

No.

Jimmy Rollins

 

[Filthy Dangles]

No.

Jimmy Rollins

No

Buster Posey and Yadier Molina

 

[NHL WAR]

No

Buster Posey and Yadier Molina

Yes to both. Molina might take a few years, though.

Paul Goldschmidt

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

No

Buster Posey and Yadier Molina

Buster - yes because he is time on his side

Yadi - no because as a hitter he just didn’t contribute enough. Didn’t really get going until age 28 and then had 4-5 good years at the plate

——-

Lance Berkman

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Yes to both. Molina might take a few years, though.

Paul Goldschmidt

As of now, no, but he’s got time. He’ll need almost an equally strong second half of his career though.

Lance Berkman

 

[tony d]

Berkman- Yes

Josh Donaldson

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Berkman- Yes

Josh Donaldson

Nope. Started too late and can’t see him being elite into his late 30s which is what he will need to do to get to the hall.

Todd Helton

 

[MMC]

Nope. Started too late and can’t see him being elite into his late 30s which is what he will need to do to get to the hall.

Todd Helton

Yes

Aroldis Chapman

 

[tony d]

No

Dale Murphy

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

No

Dale Murphy

No. Back to back MVPs are great but he didn’t deserve it the first year at all. But regardless of that, his overall numbers just don’t stack up. Great peak but not enough career wise.

Jose Altuve

 

[rangerssharks414]

No. Back to back MVPs are great but he didn’t deserve it the first year at all. But regardless of that, his overall numbers just don’t stack up. Great peak but not enough career wise.

Jose Altuve

No since he isn't eligible yet (only played nine seasons)... he's definitely on a Hall of Fame track, though.

This one may seem really stupid, but he has a better case than, say, Lee Smith.

Francisco Rodriguez

 

[Filthy Dangles]

No. Closers have to be the absolute cream of their all-time crop and KRod is just below that. And one questionable addition can't get other questionable/undeserving inducted. Also not seeing how he has a better case than Smith.

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

No. Closers have to be the absolute cream of their all-time crop and KRod is just below that. And one questionable addition can't get other questionable/undeserving inducted. Also not seeing how he has a better case than Smith.

Post another player to continue the game plz